(2,497 words)
We first hear about him after soundcheck at a gig in Haggerston.
Early into meeting Stove Eater, the band we’re there to open for (a fuzzy blend of goth and shoegaze, all anguish and philosophy but with a punchy, danceable groove), one of them abruptly cuts through the introductions to conspiratorially inform us that the Watcher Owl was spotted in this venue the previous week. Our blank faces both surprise and delight them – they clearly get a kick out of breaking this story.
They’re a two-piece, Stove Eater, a guy and girl, both small, stocky, and broad-shouldered, matching nose-rings and hair that comes to their shoulders. We’re by the bar, a drink in hand (the promotor made it very clear that we’re entitled to one complimentary drink each – cans, not pints), an hour or so before doors open, and the two of them end up having us kind of encircled, even though we outnumber them, the three of us somehow all backed up right against the edge of the counter.
They tell us someone’s started popping up at shows all over the city. A lone man, dressed in a dark navy suit, open-buttoned shirt down to his chest. He doesn’t talk to anyone, doesn’t go to the bar, doesn’t dance or move his feet or nod his head or use his phone. He finds a spot and stands there, usually towards the back but not so far that he can’t be seen from the stage. He’s not trying to hide – he wants the band to know he’s there.
“Okay,” Angie, our bassist, says, folding her arms, unimpressed. “So why’s he called that?”
Stove Eater exchange a look and grin, visibly delighted that they’ve been teed up so perfectly.
“His mask,” the girl says.
“What mask?”
“Clue is in the name.”
“He wears an owl mask?”
The girl nods and presses her hand over her face, her eyes shining through her splayed fingers. “Covers his whole face. Black porcelain, grey feathers sticking out on either side. All you can see are his eyes – dark and beady. Watching. Judging.”
“Judging?”
“That’s why he’s there. Like an A&R vigilante. He comes, he watches, and he decides if the band’s gonna blow up or not.”
“How’s he do that?” I do little to hide the bemusement in my voice, and she lets her hand drop from her face rather sourly.
“Well, whoever he is, he’s got power. After he sees a band, one of two things happens – they go big, or they fold. He’s like an omen. He turns up, your world’s about to change – for better, or for worse.”
Stove Eater then get called for soundcheck, and the three of us head outside for a cigarette. Kerry, our drummer, is the most taken by the story, and starts asking around online for anyone else who’s heard it. Angie wants to focus on the gig, and starts running a riff change by me, miming in the air with her fingers, sounding the notes out to me in a hum. I find that I’m not really listening to her – instead, my attention can’t help but drift towards Kerry, hunched over her phone, typing quickly.
Suddenly, she exclaims that someone’s got back to her – the singer from Candy Buttons, a glitzy and glitchy pop-metal mash-up, who says that the Watcher Owl came to a show, after they’d already played, to see a band called Twitchfingers. Apparently, he behaved exactly as Stove Eater described – kept to himself, made no attempts to engage with anyone, wouldn’t reply when spoken to. He watched the show and left as soon as the last note was played. Twitchfingers broke up soon after. For whatever reason, after that, no one would book them anymore, like they’d suffered a city-wide blacklist for an offence they weren’t aware of.
Over the course of the night, more and more answers start to trickle through to Kerry, who announces each of them with glee. More sightings, more accounts. More bands he descended on, dissolving in his wake.
Kerry asks Stove Eater if they know of any success stories that have followed him. The guy asks if we’ve ever heard of Wreckwood. Turns out Angie has, and she gets involved now, her interest suddenly piqued. She searches them up, turns her phone to face us. Half a million monthly listeners, an upcoming show at Troxy. Angie asks Stove Eater what they know about Wreckwood’s interactions with the Watcher Owl. The singer replies that there weren’t any – he came to a show at the Amersham Arms, and a week later they were signed. They never heard from him, and haven’t seen him at any other gigs since.
We end up playing a fierce set, more than a little fired up by all this mythologising, and I can tell that each of us searches the crowd a touch more keenly than we normally would, our attention not on each other or our playing but on who could be out there, unseen. Despite the small turnout, my eyes don’t stop roaming the back walls, the edge of the bar, the corner by the door.
Our energy levels drop once we come offstage to confirm that our lives have not, in fact, been changed tonight. We sink into our drinks as Stove Eater start up, and as good as we thought we’d played, we can’t deny that they end up blowing us out of the water with a much richer, more crushing set.
Something changes after that night. Now that we’ve heard of the Watcher Owl, we can’t seem to escape him. At our next show two weeks later, he’s all anyone can talk about. Apparently, there have been three sightings in the last month – one in Hackney, one in Clapton, one in Shepherd’s Bush. Kerry makes sure to get contacts for everyone we talk to that has a story to report, and she goes on to make a forum to coalesce all the chatter, try and map out his movements, search for patterns, predict his next appearance.
Then a show in Peckham happens, a busy one, rowdy and overspilling with an unexpectedly large audience for a new act called JARD, who only have one recently released single to their name but earned them a load of on-the-ground buzz that’s sure to soon trickle up. Kerry’s phone starts blowing up mid-rehearsal – photos and videos streaming in as people document him. We crowd around her phone, and in someone’s livestream we can see them interrogating him, getting in his face with loud, probing questions, demanding his identity, asking who he works for. The whole time he keeps his arms folded, doesn’t move or react, until someone tries to grab his mask and yank it from his face. He knocks their arm away and turns and runs. The camera feed then becomes indecipherable as the person recording gives pursuit, but eventually the image settles and we see their face against the dark night sky, lit up under a streetlamp, panting, bent over their knees, saying that they’ve lost him.
Two weeks later word gets around that JARD have called it quits. Details are scarce, but their social media goes down and their lone track is pulled. Kerry tries to reach out to the members and set up a meeting, but all her attempts are ignored, until one of them finally tells her to back off or they’ll report her.
After that night in Peckham, sightings of the Watcher Owl completely dry up. Kerry’s forum community go round as many gigs as they can asking questions, leaving stickers on walls and in toilets that read ‘Who watches the Watcher Owl?’, but they get nothing back. A few false accounts come through every now and then, and a copycat Watcher even shows up at a couple of shows for a punk duo called Flavour!! but is soon debunked as a marketing ploy.
“It’s over, Kerry,” Angie says one rehearsal, rolling her eyes as Kerry sits on her drum-stool frantically responding to a new lead that claims to have deduced that the Watcher Owl will be making his return tonight at the Sebright Arms. “He got too well-known, and now he’s given up.”
“He might have taken the mask off,” Kerry replies, not looking up, “but that doesn’t mean he isn’t still coming to shows.”
“So what if he is?”
“Don’t you want to know his deal?”
“I don’t think it really matters now.”
“He must be someone with influence.”
“Or attention-seeker plus coincidence.”
A few months later we’re soundchecking for a show in a small pub in Walthamstow, when the promotor comes in to interrupt us. He’s eager to announce that we’ve hit capacity – no more tickets will be sold, not even on the door. Our jaws hit the floor. We’ve been doing modestly enough plugging away at shows and putting a few releases out, but we’re still yet to cultivate a real audience for ourselves, with only a few semi-regulars and an energetic enough response to our gigs that is yet to convert into online listeners.
We put our heads together outside over an urgent few cigarettes, discussing how the hell this could have happened. Angie is adamant it’s a response to our last single, which has our highest listener count so far and she believes is going to be our breakout. She reminds us that we sold all the merch we brought to our last gig, which admittedly only amounted to five t-shirts and ten CDs but still, it was more than we’d ever managed to achieve – until now. Kerry, however, stays silent. When Angie notices and clasps an arm around her, trying to coax out some excitement, Kerry smiles dutifully and nods along, but she seems distracted, her mind elsewhere. She catches my eye. I’m not entirely sure what she’s thinking, but I can bet what it will be about.
The time of our set nears, but the basement stage-space remains completely empty. We head upstairs to the main bar to try and find the promotor, ask what’s happening, but he’s nowhere to be found. We go back down, talk to the sound engineer, but he says he knows as much as we do. Confused, upset, we end up sitting onstage with our instruments dejectedly, watching the time tick nearer and nearer to our start and the room remain cavernously, offensively empty.
And then, on the stroke of nine, the door at the top of the staircase opens. We stiffen. I look back at Kerry, but her eyes are fixed on the stairs. Her face has gone pale. I notice her leg is bobbing up and down relentlessly. Angie notices too, and looks from Kerry to me.
Footsteps walking down the stairs. It’s clear enough that it’s only one person. I’m expecting the promotor to emerge, to explain whatever baffling mistake was made, maybe the wrong event date listed or a glitched out system that declared a sell-out before a single ticket was shifted.
Kerry clocks it before he’s fully visible, throwing her hand to her mouth with a sharp, sudden intake of breath. Sleek black brogues, a navy suit so dark it shines like water in moonlight. Open-collared shirt. And then, there it is – black porcelain mask, grey speckled feathers sticking out on either side.
The Watcher Owl enters the room and comes to stand in the centre. We stare at him. He watches us. I can’t make out his eyes in the dim basement lights. Just the mask – no sign of life beneath it.
Eventually, he breaks our standoff when he lifts his watch, inspects it, then looks to the sound engineer, who turns to us, unsure. I’m frozen, and I can feel Angie equally blindsided beside me. It’s Kerry instead who takes control. She sits up, straightens her back, rolls her drumstick in a neat circle round her fingers, and starts up with single, driving kicks to the bass drum, opening up our first song. Angie and I scramble slightly, jumping into position. The three of us make eye contact – Kerry nods firmly. It’s the push we need, and I start to dig up my own confidence, feel her motivation take hold of me. I let her do an extra few bars of the intro before I come screeching in, and Angie lights her bass up beside me and we’re off.
I feel hyperaware of every sound we make, every note out of my mouth, every throb of bass or bite of snare. There’s no hiding up here with an empty room, no crowd to play off, no energy to set the tone or atmosphere to motivate us. Kerry falls out of time in one track and Angie has to pull her back with a frantic stare and a stamped foot. I stumble my words over one of our faster songs and have to cover it by lurching into an impromptu scream, but it seems to play and sets me up to slide into the chorus neatly enough.
All the while he just stands there, arms folded, unmoving, seemingly uncaring. We screech to a halt at the end of our set, a deliberately abrupt and jarring finish that’s meant to precipitate a call for an encore, but I gesture urgently to the others to keep it going and we leap a little too quickly into the finale. Angie and Kerry play the ending instrumental out with fury, adding a lot of extra licks and fills that bring the set to a bruising, pulsing close. Panting, adrenalized, we turn in unison to our single spectator.
A pause. And then, he turns on his heels and strides from the room. I want to chase after him, but I can’t bring myself to move. I want to yell, berate him, but my mind is blank and ringing with anxiety and shock.
We don’t look at each other until the door closes and the basement is empty once more. Kerry breaks down, collapsing over her snare drum and letting herself fall into great heaving sobs. Angie is shaking, and she sets her bass down on the ground far harder than I’m sure she meant to, and when it slides off the amp to hit the floor with a discordant thud, she doesn’t do anything to correct it.
I drop into a squat, push my face into my hands. I feel naked. Intruded on. I draw my arms tightly around my shoulders, squeeze myself as hard as I can.
We stay like that for some time, hunched into ourselves on the stage. When we finally move upstairs and huddle at the bar in silence, I know we all share the same invasive, lingering sensation, and parting ways after a single half-hearted drink I walk to the bus stop tense and alert, glancing over my shoulder every few steps, still feeling every bit as watched out here in the street as I did back in the grip of that hidden, porcelain stare.
.
THE END
Bio
Will Pinhey is a multidisciplinary writer across film, theatre, and prose fiction. His debut feature film ‘Mother Maker Lover Taker’ premiered at Unrestricted View Film Festival in May 2024, winning the Festival Director’s Choice Award. He has previously won the National Theatre’s New Views playwriting competition, and had theatrical work performed at Theatre503, The Bread & Roses Theatre, and the Edinburgh Fringe. His short stories can be found published with Idle Ink, Crow & Cross Keys, The Horizon, and Literally Stories.
More
- Night Shift Politics by Michael Wegener
- Shangri-La by Robert M. Ingram
- Pauli by Matt Gossman
- The Butterfly Collector by Eamonn Furey
- Intoxication by Lynda Williams
Transference: A brutal and lyrical Manchester crime thriller
A city stained with blood. A past that won’t stay buried. A detective who can’t walk away.
When ex-SAS John Black is dragged into a deadly game of secrets and revenge, Manchester’s underworld erupts in chaos. A brutal killing, a cryptic message, and a sinister force pulling the strings—Black must navigate a city teetering on the edge, where trust is a luxury and violence is currency.
As ghosts from his past collide with a case that’s dangerously personal, Black is forced to confront his own demons before they consume him. But in a world where power is won with blood, can he survive long enough to uncover the truth?
Perfect for fans of Ian Rankin, Val McDermid, and gritty, noir-soaked crime fiction, Transference is a relentless thriller packed with razor-sharp writing, brutal twists, and a darkly poetic heart.

