Short Story

Windfall by E.A. Mayer

Share this article

When Martin sees the weathervane on the steeple of the abandoned church—thanks to a random skyward glance on his morning run around Bedford—he knows exactly who will buy it. This is his talent, although it hadn’t prevented him from receiving a rating of Needs Improvement in his latest performance review at Tipton’s. He just needs an opportunity to redeem himself—to connect the dots between object and collector. And there is it: backlit by the weak November sun. 

That afternoon, he confirms his initial hunch through binoculars. The weathervane is a Hutchfield & Sons stallion model, circa 1872, with all the bells and whistles: muscled chest, rippling mane, legs in full gallop, and an embossed H&Co. stamp on its underbelly. Even better, it has a terrific verdigris patina, marred only by streaks of bird shit and a small bullet hole on the left side which, in the quirky economics of the trade, is a mark of authenticity that will boost its value significantly. The last weathervane of this caliber was hammered down at Sotheby’s for $5.8 million. At the professional level, collecting is a contact sport, and his gut tells him that George and Helena Krantz will pay a substantial sum to possess it, if only to keep it out of the collections of their fellow point-one-percenters. They have probably driven—been driven—past this shabby chapel countless times on the way to their North Salem horse farm. 

Martin has a puzzle to solve. In normal circumstances, an acquisition of this magnitude would be relatively straightforward; however, the focus of this deal, roughly two-and-a-half stories in the air, poses obvious challenges. 

After a few hours of online searching, he learns that the church building was once a house of worship for a dying offshoot of Congregationalists but now exists in a state of legal limbo. A Greenwich developer has been skirmishing with a committee of underfunded preservationists over the vacant husk of the building and its slate-toothed cemetery. That makes it fair game. He is simply liberating a priceless artifact from potential destruction. Why wouldn’t he? Hadn’t the same logic built and filled the world’s museums?

Share this article