I first met Monroe Carter after he’d killed himself. He’d taken his own life before, but I’m getting ahead of myself.
I’m an insurance investigator.
Typically, I spend my time waiting around in a car, lurking in alleyways, or just blending into the background. Some guy tries to collect on worker’s compensation by claiming he threw his back out on the job. I follow him around for a couple of days and wait. The picture I take of him bowling negates his claim and convicts him of insurance fraud.
It was during an investigation I met Carter.
The coffee had been doing a decent job battling against a hangover when my boss called. He explained the situation to me as being a top priority. I tried to weasel out of it, but he was firm. As I hung up the phone, I accidentally spilt coffee onto my pant leg. I let rip a series of expletives, then caught the six train uptown. Carter lived in an apartment on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. When I arrived, the police were already on the scene.
“Yeah, Carter,” I told the doorman. He was wearing a burgundy uniform with a matching cap and had a surly demeanour; probably pissed at the number of cops in the lobby messing up his routine.
“8D,” he said. I nodded and quickly made my way toward the elevator bank hoping to avoid any further animosity.
The apartment had already been cordoned off with yellow caution tape. The door was open, but a uniformed patrolman had been posted to the side. I showed him my credentials, and he let me pass.
I stepped into the living room and admired the view. Monroe Carter had just been promoted to CEO of an import/export company, which meant he needed life insurance.
A flashbulb went off as I walked into the bedroom. The crime scene photographer, a runty guy with the nose of a larger man, had an unlit cigar wedged into the corner of his mouth.
“Shame,” he said and continued to chomp on the end of it. Carter’s body lay crumpled on the bed. He’d placed a nickel-plated .45 against the side of his head and pulled the trigger. His skull had been scorched black by powder burns. Brain matter decorated sections of the comforter. Blood pooled around the body and ran down the corner of the bed and had congealed onto the carpet.
Still, Carter had a peaceful look on his face.
I stood there and took in the smell of cordite. I was occasionally jarred by the flash of the camera, and the hum of the forensic team which combed the room for evidence. The gun was bagged, and the room was inspected for fibres and residue. All I had to do now was wait for them to rule out foul play. I nodded to the photographer on the way out.
“Damn shame,” he repeated. I noticed the cigar butt was gone and, as I made my way back through the hallway I couldn’t help but be overcome by the feeling he’d eaten it.
“You idiots!” screamed a rather shrill voice, “he was murdered!”
I walked toward the sound of the voice and into the kitchen. Mrs Carter, or so I suspected, held court with two plainclothes detectives.
“Those bastards! They killed him!” she repeated.
“Ma’am please try to calm down.”
She took a deep breath and inhaled half of the glass of wine in her hand in one pull and didn’t even flinch. It had taken me years of practice to do that. She wore some kind of low cut dress which accentuated all the right places and even some of the wrong ones.
I could tell immediately she was not a woman to be trifled with.
“We’re sorry about this, Mrs Carter, but it looks like an ironclad suicide,” The Senior Detective said. He had a weathered face like the job had prematurely aged him.
“Listen to me. My husband’s killer is out there somewhere; find him!”
The younger of the two detectives, who hadn’t seen enough of the world yet to know better, voiced his opinion.
“If he was murdered,” he began to say and walked over so they only stood about a foot away from each other. “That would make you a suspect too, wouldn’t it?” She didn’t reply. He turned to look at his partner. “Maybe we should take you downtown and have you fingerprinted?”
“You arrogant simpleton,” she began. I wished I had popcorn.
“Do you really think I’d offer the theory that my husband was murdered if I had anything to do with it? I believe the phrase ‘ironclad suicide’ was used not one minute ago. Now, I didn’t murder my husband, but someone did. Go find them!” She punctuated the last part of her diatribe by slamming her fist on the table. Both detectives tucked their tails between their legs and backed out of the kitchen.
“If you think of anything that might help us,” The Senior Detective managed to say and handed over his business card. She watched them leave without saying a word. She killed the wine in her glass.
“Enjoying the show?” She asked aloud without turning around.
“I-uh.”
She turned to face me, and I got a good look at her for the first time. She was stunning.
“Who are you?” She asked. A hint of anger had crept back into her voice. She threw the detective’s card in the trash.
“I’m from Jones and Biggs.”
Mrs. Carter eyed me suspiciously until she recognized the name then warmed up a bit.
“Have a seat. Would you care for a drink?”
“Scotch’d be great,” I offered. Mrs. Carter fixed me a double and refreshed her own.
“As I’m sure you already know, Mr. Carter had a policy with us,” I said.
“Oh?” She said. Her tone suggested she was surprised. Her charade might have fooled a lesser man, but I’m greater than most.
“Mrs. Carter.”
“Please call me Cynthia.” She radiated charm, and I basked in its warmth.
“You stand to inherit a large sum of money.”
She sat down at the table and crossed her legs. I tried better to hide my erection.
“However, if he commits suicide…” I let the words trail off.
She drank more of her wine. A petite woman like herself should be reeling from the effects, but Mrs Carter was in complete control.
“Do you have dinner plans tonight?” She asked. I tried not to look surprised, but her comment had caught me off guard. Inside I felt like a pinball machine that had gone on tilt.
“I was just going to head home after work,” I said. She rose and escorted me to the front door. She took my scotch.
“Meet me at the Jacobs club at 8 pm,” she said.
She lingered in the doorway. When the elevator arrived, I got inside. Before the elevator doors closed she spoke.
“And wear something that hides the tent in your pants.”
Damn.
***
I got back to the office and typed up my preliminary report.
So far, as the detective said, it looked to be an ironclad suicide. The body had been taken to the morgue for an autopsy. The bedspread, firearm, and clothes were all being processed. The only thing I could do was wait for the fingerprints on the weapon to be confirmed as Carter’s to close the case. In the meantime, I combed through the Carter policy and decided to call it a day.
The Jacobs club was a five-star restaurant that overlooked the City from the top of a skyscraper. I waited at the bar until she arrived. The elevator doors opened directly into the restaurant, and she emerged in a platinum gown. Diamonds dripped from her body, and her fragrance was intoxicating. The Maitre D trotted over and took her mink. I left my spot at the bar and walked over.
“Mrs. Carter, we are so sorry to hear the horrible news.”
“Thank you, Friedrich,” she said and frowned.
“Your usual table is ready whenever you are,” he said, bowed, and scampered off to greet the next party.
“You clean up pretty well,” she said.
“Thank you.”
We took a secluded table at the back of the restaurant. From our vantage point, the skyline of the City was breathtaking. She hardly noticed; I’m guessing it would take a lot to impress her. We ordered drinks and our food without looking at the menu.
“I take it you’re a steak man?” She said before the waiter could solicit my order.
“He’ll have the porterhouse, medium rare,” Mrs. Carter said.
“Very good ma’am.” The waiter said and vanished.
She adjusted herself in her seat and presented an ample bosom. It’s a good thing I was wearing briefs.
“How do you like working for Jones and Biggs?” She asked casually like we were two old friends catching up.
“It’s fine; pays the bills.”
“But you’d like something more wouldn’t you?”
“That depends.” I shifted in my chair. “Why don’t you tell me about Mr. Carter?
“No business tonight.”
The waiter arrived with our drinks and she lifted her glass.
“We can start mourning tomorrow.” It wasn’t like I didn’t know about their relationship. Carter had married Cynthia a little over six years ago. Now, here she was in a position to make a little over fifty million dollars if the insurance policy was enforced.
I remained the final obstacle, and she knew it. She distinctly had the upper hand. I tried to rattle her a bit by asking about her husband, but she was smooth. The food arrived and I asked for another scotch.
“I hope you like your steak,” Cynthia offered. I took a bite and it practically melted in my mouth. A guy could get used to this. I tried to remind myself to keep a level head, but my id was having a field day.
By the time we left the restaurant, she had me wrapped around her finger.
***
We lay under the covers and she lit a cigarette. I couldn’t help thinking about the fact I’d just made love to her in the bed her husband died in not twenty-four hours previously.
She sensed my apprehension and ran her finger up my chest.
“Have the results come back on Carter’s autopsy?” She asked and blew a smoke ring into the air.
“Not for another day.”
She sat up in bed and faced me.
“When that report comes back, it’s going to confirm what we both know to be true.”
“Monroe killed himself?”
“The bastard.” She stubbed her cigarette out and stood naked next to the bed.
“Change it for me,” Cynthia said, and like a panther circled to my side.
“Excuse me?”
“You’re the only one who can do it. Make it look like a homicide. Do whatever you have to do.” She slithered into bed and began to kiss my neck.
“I’ll be a rich woman, and I know how to return a favor.”
The wheels in my head had spun out of control. I thought about my shabby apartment tucked above a bowling alley. She manoeuvred on top of me, and at that moment I lost any shred of integrity that I had left.
***
The plan was simple. I’d bribe the morgue attendant or just sneak in and doctor the evidence. It was a Friday night, and odds were they’d wait until Monday to begin processing everything. The body would be on ice until then and susceptible. I arrived at the morgue a little past two in the morning. The place was dead; forgive the pun. I adjusted the pork pie hat on my head and tried the door. It was locked but easily picked. After all, who’d want to break into a morgue? It was pitch black inside, and I turned on my penlight. I headed toward the cold chambers toward the back. I got to the double doors, which led further into the morgue, took a deep breath, and reflected on how the Hell I’d gotten into this predicament when I heard a scream which came from further ahead.
Before I could do anything the double doors flung open, and I was tossed back onto the ground. I aimed the penlight and saw it was Monroe Carter. He had a confused look on his face and stared at me for a second. Oh, and he was completely naked. Another scream came from the room, and it woke Carter from his stupor. He ran out the front door. I scrambled to my feet and went through the double doors. Seated on the floor was a morgue attendant.
“He was dead. Then he was alive.” She finally focused on me.
She’d been given quite a scare, but she would be okay. I bolted in the direction Carter had gone.
***
“You have a problem.”
“What do you mean I have a problem?” Cynthia barked at me. I was in a phone booth a few blocks from the morgue.
“I can’t get into it right now,” I said.
“Well, you’d better fix it whatever it is because it’s your problem too.” With that, she played a recording over the phone of me agreeing to tamper with the evidence in her insurance case.
Damn, she was good.
“Now fix it,” She said and hung up the phone.
I had to find Carter and figure out what the Hell was going on. A light rain had started, so I pulled my coat tight around my body. Where would a naked man go? Strike that, where would a recently back from the dead naked man go? As I tried to wrap my mind around the fact the man had pulled a Lazarus the sky opened up. I knew I had to take refuge somewhere, so I ducked into some dive on the corner. It was empty; except for the bartender. I shook my coat out and plunked down at the bar.
“What can I get you?” The bartender was a stocky fellow with slicked-back hair and a handlebar moustache.
“I’ll have a Cutty Sark, neat,” I told the bartender who left to go and fix my drink.
When he returned I slipped him a fifty.
“Keep ’em coming till that runs out,” I said, and took a half of it in one pull.
“You got it.” He moved further down the bar to watch the game on one of the television sets.
I drank in silence. I had been suckered in by Cynthia, and now she played me like a marionette. As long as she had that recording, I was in her pocket. She could spin Carter’s disappearance from the morgue any way she wanted and pin it on me. I’d be labelled a body snatcher or worse.
Cynthia, of course, would get everything she desired. Without a body, there’d be no death certificate, and the case would remain open. I’m sure her lawyers would be able to find the loophole which entitled her access to the full amount from the policy regardless of whether they could ever find Carter’s body.
“Hey buddy, no clothes no service,” the bartender called out to a newly arrived patron.
What were the odds?
I turned around and there, dripping wet, with a towel wrapped around his waist, stood Monroe Carter.
“Please,” he said.
“Sorry pal, rules of the house,” the bartender replied.
Carter sighed and turned to leave.
“Hey, wait up,” I blurted. Carter continued to walk, so I thanked the bartender and followed Carter out of the bar.
“Hey, Carter!” He stopped and turned around. There was a brief glimpse of surprise on his face. He recognized me, but couldn’t place it.
“Why don’t we get you some clothes and something to drink?” I took off my jacket and handed it to him. He eyed me suspiciously but took the coat. I hailed a cab. Carter remained silent as we rode toward my apartment. I tried not to stare, but I noticed the wound on his temple, where the bullet entered, had almost entirely healed at this point.
He remained uncommunicative until he had a stiff drink in his hand. I’d also given him clothes to wear. He sat on my couch while I occupied the easy chair across from him.
“I know you from somewhere don’t I?” he said finally.
“At the morgue this evening,” I replied. He shook his head and snapped his fingers as the memory came flooding back.
“Jesus.” He rubbed the bridge of his nose. “I don’t know which is worse, being sore from rigour mortis or…” he trailed off, stood up, and stretched.
“Can I get another of these?” He asked. I fixed us both up and sat back down.
“So,” I began, “would you mind telling me what the Hell is going on?”
“When I was fifteen, I committed suicide.” He stirred his drink with his finger and licked it.
“I listened to Iggy Pop’s The Idiot, watched Werner Herzog’s Stroszek, and hanged myself.”
“Why does that sound familiar?”
“It’s how Ian Curtis went.”
“Hold on, I know it. Wait, don’t tell me.”
“He was the lead singer of Joy Division.”
“Ah! Right!- you did the same thing?”
He took another sip of his drink but didn’t answer.
“So, what’s the deal?”
“Well, I did some research. Apparently, throughout history, there have been a few cases of people with the ability to take their own life and return.” He paused and lifted both arms in the air like a magician who’s just done his encore. I leaned back in my chair.
“So, you’re immortal?” I asked.
“Not quite. According to the research, these people could only take their own lives and come back. I can still be killed by someone else.” He paused and looked me square in the eye. “Some people would pay a lot of money for this information.”
“Like your wife?”
“My wife…” he said, with the sound of disgust in his voice. “I wish I could have seen her face when she found my body.” He chuckled to himself and took another sip of his drink. He didn’t notice that I produced a 22 From my ankle holster.
“Now that you mention it, we should probably talk about your wife.”
The smile left his face, and he fixed me with an angry look.
“Who are you?” He asked through gritted teeth.
“That all depends,” I said and cocked the hammer to let him know I was serious. He nonchalantly killed his drink. If I thought his wife was a cool customer, this guy was ice cold.
“I’m listening,” he said and folded his arms across his chest.
“I work for Jones and Biggs,” I said and kept the weapon on him at all times.
“As you know, a suicide essentially cancels out your life insurance, so you’re wife asked me-”
“My wife!” The hatred seethed from him.
“She had been planning to kill me, I just beat her to it,” Carter said. He finished his drink and continued “So, you’re the patsy, huh? I don’t blame you. She could drive a man to his grave.” He smiled at his choice of words.
“So now what?” He asked.
“Well, I could shoot you, bring you back to the morgue, and fulfill my end of the bargain.”
“Do you think my wife is going to run off with you into the sunset?”
As I pondered the answer to that question, he grabbed the paring knife from my makeshift bar and put it to his own neck. I raised the gun and aimed it at his head.
“The question now,” he said without a trace of fear in his voice, “Is whether you think you can shoot me before I slit my own throat? If you’re right, well, kudos. But, if you’re wrong, well, then.”
He was right, I couldn’t even begin to comprehend the pickle I’d be in. I’d have to deal with Carter’s body rising from the grave all over again. That problem would exponentially multiply, and Murphy’s law would eat me for dinner. I rested the hammer down and handed him my gun.
“OK Mr. Carter, you’re calling the shots now, what do we do?”
“I think we should pay a visit to my wife.”
***
Cynthia was up when I arrived.
She greeted me at the front door wearing a half-open robe. Both of her hands contained drinks. I took mine and pressed past her into the living room.
“So, our problem is over?” She said.
She approached me and put her arm around my waist. I had telephoned her before I showed up and told her that we needed to meet.
“Not really,” came a voice from behind us. I took a big gulp of scotch to prepare myself. We both turned around. Carter stood in the doorway.
“Good to see you again, Cynthia.”
She looked at me. Her mouth had gone wide. It was the only time I’d ever seen her rattled, but she composed herself rather quickly.
“You look well, ‘Money’ all things considered. Why don’t the three of us adjourn to the living room?” She led the way and we both followed. Along the way, Carter stopped to make a drink for himself and soon joined us.
The tension in the room was palpable.
“So, here we all are,” Cynthia said.
“You really are something.” Carter spewed the words out like they were daggers. He stood up and removed my 22 From behind his back. If she was scared, she didn’t show it. By this point, Cynthia had completely reverted to the coldhearted woman I’d first met.
“Oh ‘Money,’” she began, “you’re not going to kill me.”
“Really? Why’s that?”
“Because you’re already dead.”
Carter started to laugh. Then the side of his face began to twitch. He belched and blinked his eyes. The weapon fell out of his hand onto the floor and he doubled over.
“What’s going on?” he said.
“Poison.” She swirled the wine in her glass and then gulped some down. “Pretty soon you’re going to go into convulsions, and then your heart is going to seize.”
Carter fell to the floor. His face had turned red and the veins in the side of his neck had become varicose. He tried to speak, but his airflow had been restricted. In another thirty-second he was dead. I watched the whole scene without making a noise. I looked down at my drink and felt my stomach turn. The glass fell from my hand and shattered on the floor.
“Oh, relax, your drink isn’t poisoned.” She drained her wine and walked over to examine Carter’s body.
“You knew, didn’t you? This whole time. You knew he wasn’t dead, that he’d come back?” I said.
“Give me a little bit of credit. Help me. We’ve got to get his body to the morgue.” I sat motionless at first. I was unsure of anything.
“This is the last piece of the puzzle, now hurry,” she said. I took a deep breath and sprung into action. Soon we had rolled Carter’s body up in a Persian rug and taped up the ends.
I waited in the stairwell with the rug, while she went for the car.
A few minutes later, Cynthia pulled up her Cadillac to the side entrance. Together, we placed the body in the back seat. Once I climbed aboard we sped off toward the morgue. When we got there the rain had finally stopped. The place was empty this time. We unwrapped the body and put him back in the freezer. I started to roll up the rug when I heard the hammer of my .22. I lifted my head to see Cynthia had pointed the piece right at me.
“Don’t take it personally.” She said. “It could have been anyone, but you were at the right place, at the right time, with the right credentials.”
“I’d like to think that I differentiated myself in other ways.”
“Now that there’s poison in my husband’s system, the policy will be enforced, and I’ll get my money. Just one last loose end.”
“There’s just one thing you didn’t count on,” I said and shot her with my concealed sleeve gun. A quick flick of the wrist was all it took. The bullet went into her mouth and out the back of her head. She had the chance to have one thought before she died. I like to think that she figured out what had happened, but either way, any thought would suffice. I grabbed the rug and dragged it to the incinerator. Afterwards, I wiped the derringer clean, removed it from the slide on my wrist, placed it into her hand, and made my way out the front door.
It was still dark outside, so I walked at a leisurely pace to not attract any attention. It would be an open and shut case. The doctored paperwork on Mr Carter would reveal he was indeed murdered. His insurance policy would pay out fifty million to his wife. Unfortunately, her grief had been too much for her to bear, and during the middle of the night, after breaking into the morgue to see his body one last time, she had taken her own life. Therefore, the money would be transferred to the next of kin, or in this case a designated beneficiary. Wouldn’t you know, only a day before Mrs Carter instructed the money to be placed in escrow in a Swiss Bank account; my Swiss Bank account.
It wasn’t that difficult to make some adjustments to her policy during my preliminary paperwork. You see, I’m an insurance investigator, and I like to think I’m pretty good at my job.
THE END
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Andrew Davie received an MFA in creative writing from Adelphi University. He taught English in Macau on a Fulbright Grant. In June of 2018, he survived a ruptured brain aneurysm and subarachnoid haemorrhage. His crime fiction novella Pavement was released in by All Due Respect Books. The follow-up Ouroboros is scheduled for December 2020 and his novella Dig Two Graves is scheduled to be released by Close to the Bone in September 2020. His other work can be found in links on his website: asdavie.wordpress.com
