Share this article

Tuesday morning and a couple of us local boys are sitting at the counter in Loretta’s Café.  Normally, we’d all be at work, seeing as it’s Tuesday. But everything in Wester’s Corner has been shut down because of the rain. Loretta’s is just about the only place still open, so that’s why we’re here, shooting the shit.  What everybody’s talking about, of course, is the storm that’s been raging for more than a week, dumping almost a foot of rain on the valley and causing Armbruster Creek to overflow and close State Route 57, the main highway running through town.

“Heard on the radio that they’re going to have to evacuate the whole valley if the rain don’t let up by tomorrow,” Carl says. “Worst storm on record, they say.”

“I’ve lived here in Wester’s Corner my whole life,” I say. “It’s the worst I’ve ever seen and I’m damn near fifty.”

Ben Jackson turns on his stool and points toward the street.

“Isn’t that Wayne Miller pulling up there?” he asks.

We all turn to look. The café’s plate glass windows are streaked with rain and partially fogged up, but we can still make out an old Chevy pickup pulling into a parking space across the street. The lights shut off and Wayne opens the truck door, steps out and begins sprinting across the street, splashing through puddles and almost falling down at one point.

He opens the café door and dashes inside, dripping wet from the rain and out of breath from running. He stomps his feet briefly on a doormat that’s already soaking wet, then walks to the counter and takes a seat beside us.

“This rain don’t stop pretty soon, it’s going to drown us all,” he says.

Carl takes a sip of coffee and shakes his head.

“Yeah, you could be right, there, Wayne,” he says. “Did you hear it took out that old Screaming James Bridge up there on Punk Hollow Road? Knocked it completely off the foundation and carried it a hundred feet downstream.”

“Hell, you know that hill up there on Armbruster Creek, where the Seifert place is?” Wayne says.

“Close to that old cemetery?” I ask. “The one they bull-dozed a month or so ago to make way for the Route 57 by-pass?”

‘Yeah that one,” Wayne says, “Well, the whole side of that hill’s slid into the creek, the Seifert house and all. They say Auntie Maude went in with it. Haven’t found her yet but apparently she’s presumed dead.”

Loretta, the café owner, is behind the counter checking her phone messages. Wayne raises his hand to get her attention. Then he mouths the word ‘coffee.’ Loretta puts her phone in her pocket and grabs a glass coffee pot off the burner. She sets a porcelain cup in front of Wayne and begins pouring coffee. 

“So who’s this new fellow that came into town the other day? Any of you guys know?”  she asks, “Scar on his left cheek, like he might have been in a car accident. Kind of a funny accent, they say. Ohio, maybe, or someplace up north.”

We all look at each other and shrug.

“Damned if I know,” Carl says.

“I saw him down at the Double Shot last night,” Charlie Walters says. “He walks in, sits down right next to me at the bar and orders a beer. That scar you was talking about, Loretta, looks too clean to be from a car accident. I’d say more likely a knife fight. Anyway, I tried to strike up a conversation. All I got out of him was that he’s in town on business. He didn’t seem very friendly and I didn’t press it. He just sits there, real quiet-like, finishing his beer. Then he gets up and walks out without saying boo-shit.”

“I was talking to Mrs. Denton over there at the Sunoco station yesterday,” Ben Jackson says, “According to her, he walked into the gas station out of the blue a couple of days ago, soaking wet, his shoes all covered in mud. She said, he didn’t appear to be driving, so I don’t know how he got here.”

“Mrs. Denton say what he wanted?” I ask.

“She says he was pretty tight-lipped,” Ben replies. “Says all he asked was if the Walker Hotel was still open.”

“The Walker Hotel,” I say. “Hell, that place has been closed since before I was born.” 

“Yeah, I think Baldy back there,” Loretta nods her head in the direction of an old man sitting in a booth along the wall, “is about the only one around here anymore who might remember when the Walker was still open.”

“Hey, Baldy,” she shouts, “what can you tell us about the old Walker Hotel?”

Baldy gives her a quizzical look. Then he slides out of his booth and hobbles slowly up to the counter.

“Sorry, Loretta,” he says, cupping his hand behind one ear to hear better, “what was you asking me?”

“The Walker Hotel,” she says. “What can you tell us about that place?”

“The Walker?” he says. “Geez, that place closed years go. Late forties, or so. I was just a boy at the time, so my memory’s a little hazy. I do recall that it closed right after that Screaming James mess. I guess this James fellow was staying there at the time. After that, no one wanted to go near the place.”

“That whole Screaming James shit, what was the connection there?” I ask, “I’ve always been a little curious. For as long as I can remember, nobody wanted to talk about it. And, far as I know, there ain’t no written records, like newspaper stories or anything.”

“It’s not the sort of thing people wanted to put on record,” Baldy says. “It was the sort of thing people preferred to forget.” 

“A girl was raped and the locals lynched somebody for it, right?” I say.

“Allegedly raped,” Loretta says, making air quotes as she says the word “raped.”

“Didn’t it have something to do with Auntie Maude,” Wayne says, “that crazy old bat that’s just gone missing?”

Baldy lifts his baseball cap and scratches the top of his head.

“Maude Sieffert,” he says, “Her daddy was the county sheriff at the time. He was a drunkard. A real mean sonofabitch. Everyone in town was scared of him.  I was a few years behind Maude in school, but I remember her well. She was only about fourteen or fifteen at the time, a pretty little thing, as I recall. But a little…I don’t know…strange, I guess you might say.”

“We’re talking about Auntie Maude, here?” Charlie says. “That crazy woman that fired her shotgun at a UPS driver?”

“Yup, that’s the one,” Baldy says. “At the time of the incident, this fellow James had just drifted into town from someplace up north. It turned out that, a month or so after he arrived, Maude tried to run away to Louisville and had to be hunted down and returned by the Louisville police. Which led people to think that the two things might’ve been related.”

“Who was raped?” Carl asked.

“Why, it was Maude herself who claimed to have been raped,” Baldy says. “Claimed it was James who done it. She didn’t want to say at first, but her daddy beat it out of her.”

“Why’d he have to beat it out of her? Seems like that’s something she would have wanted to report herself,” Carl says. 

“Well, it turns out she was pregnant at the time,” Baldy says. “When that became obvious, her daddy was determined to find out who the father was. I guess when he started beating on her, that’s when she came up with the whole rape story. She said that she’d gone into town one day because she’d always been curious about what the Walker Hotel looked like inside. So she went in and started walking around the halls. And that’s when this James fellow grabbed her and dragged her into his room and raped her.”

“I don’t know,” Wayne says. “That seems a little fishy to me. She walked into town just so she could see what the hotel hallways looked like?”

“Well, yes, looking back, it does seem a little fishy,” Baldy says. “But at the time, people wasn’t so much interested in getting to the truth of the matter. A Yankee had raped a local girl and her daddy wanted revenge. That’s what they was thinking, mostly.”

“Anyway, old man Sieffert comes into town drunk and fit to be tied,” Baldy continues. “He starts banging on people’s doors and demanding they join him in dealing with this James fellow. Most people followed along, either because they was too scared to say no or because they didn’t much care for Yankees to begin with. A whole mob of them goes down to the Walker and storms into James’s room. They drag him out into the street, tie him up and throw him into the back of Tim McAllen’s pickup.”

“Then they all get in their cars and drive out to the steel truss bridge across Armbruster Creek. Someone pulls a rope out of the trunk of their car and ties it into a noose. They throw the noose end of the rope over one of the trusses. Tim McAllen backs his truck up under the truss and a couple of the boys jump into the bed and stand James up on his feet. But when they try to put the noose around his neck, he starts fussing and yelling. ‘What the hell did I do?’ Or something to that effect. His whole face goes white with fear and he begins twisting his body around trying to keep away from the noose. One of the boys punches him real hard in the gut and he bends over and that’s when they were finally able to get the noose around his neck. Then they pull the rope up so tight that James is just barely standing on his tiptoes in the bed of the truck.  He doesn’t say anything else. Just stands there sort of shaking and looking all wide-eyed like a dying calf in a thunderstorm.”

“They tie the other end of the rope to the bridge rail and the McAllen boy gets back into his truck, hits the accelerator and pops the clutch. The truck lurches forward, and James drops off the edge of the tail gate. The crowd lets out a cheer as the noose tightens around his neck and he begins twitching and jerking his legs. His face turns purple and his eyes are about to bulge out when, suddenly he opens his mouth and lets out this horrifying scream, a scream so loud and so piercing that it sounds like it’d come from the very bowels of Hell itself. Instead of dying, James just hangs there from the end of the rope swinging back and forth and screaming with a fiery look that seems to burn through the soul of every person in the crowd.”

“People put their hands over their ears, but they can’t block out the sound. They go back to their homes, but the scream continues into the night, a wail so loud that it can be heard all over the valley. It doesn’t stop until sunup the next morning.”

“The following day, Sheriff Sieffert and a couple of his deputies drive out to retrieve the body. But as soon as they approach the bridge, James’s eyes pop open, his mouth widens and the scream begins again, so loud that it forces the sheriff and his deputies to retreat.”

“For a month or so afterwards, nobody could approach the bridge without causing James to start screaming again. If you tried to take a team of horses up there, as soon as the wagon got close to the bridge, the scream would start up. The horses would stop in their tracks, rear up and whinny and refuse to move, no matter how hard you whipped them. If you tried to approach in a car, the scream would be so loud that it would shatter the car’s windshield. The car would start shaking real bad and wouldn’t stop until you put it in reverse and turned around.”

“That scream put the whole valley on edge for quite a while. Grown adults began wetting the bed at night. Chickens stopped laying eggs. Calves were born dead. Dogs took to killing and eating each other.”

“Finally, after the crows had pecked out James’s eyes and the flesh had begun to rot off his bones, the rope broke and his body dropped onto the deck of the bridge. Somebody—I don’t know who—found him there, nothing more than a broken lump by then, and they carried him off and buried him at that old cemetery up there by the Sieffert place.”

“The cemetery that they just bulldozed?” I ask.

“I believe so,” Baldy says, “Anyway, that’s how the bridge came to be called Screaming James Bridge.”

“What became of Auntie Maude’s baby?” Loretta says.

“The baby was born dead,” Baldy says, “And the thing is, it was born only about three months after they hanged James. Which meant, it couldn’t have been his because she’d have had to have been at least four months pregnant when he first arrived here.”

“Who’s baby was it, then?” Loretta says.

“No one ever found out,” Baldy says. “Lot of people said it might have been Sheriff Siefert’s.”

“Maude’s daddy?” Loretta says.

“Maude’s daddy,” Baldy replies. “There was rumors going around at the time about some just awful stuff going on between Maude and him. Nothing ever came of it because Sheriff Siefert was killed in a hunting accident shortly afterward. And then Maude turned into the unhinged recluse you know her as today.”

“Wasn’t there any repercussions?” Ben asked, “People from up north looking for this James guy? Or word of the whole thing spreading beyond the valley and the authorities coming to investigate?”

“You’d have thought so,” Baldy says, “But I guess James didn’t have anybody that cared enough to come looking. And as far as the people here was concerned, they just wanted to bury the whole incident and block it out of their minds.”

“Did James have a last name?” I ask out of curiosity. “What with the internet and all, it might be interesting to see if we could find anything out about him.”

“I’m sure he had one,” Baldy says. “But I couldn’t, for the life of me, tell you what it was. Never heard anybody refer to him as anything other than ‘that James fellow’ or ‘that Yankee with the scar on his cheek.’”

A sudden crack of thunder rattles the windows and puts an end to the conversation.

“I don’t guess this rain’s ever going to let up,” Baldy says, as he turns and shuffles back to his booth.

<END>


Bio

Louis Kummerer is an American writer currently living in Phoenix, Arizona. His work has been published in 10×10 Flash, New Delta Review, The Brussels Review, Bristol Noir, Grey Sparrow, Yellow Mama, Punk Noir, Micromance, CaféLit, Bright Flash Literary Review, Flash Fiction Magazine, The Chamber Magazine, Friday Flash Fiction, and 101 Words. He is a current nominee for the Pushcart Prize. A collection of his stories appears at louk247-fiction.com.


More

Share this article