(2324 words)
Saddle River, NJ
1973
The doorbell rang a second time as George watched him through the peephole. The detective looked miserable, gripping his collar and steeling himself against the damp evening. George appreciated his patience. But he couldn’t open the door yet—not until this feeling passed. The twinge, he called it. A flip of the stomach, a brief acceleration of the heart. His anxiety had been far worse as a child. Back then, the sight of a policeman sent lightning bolts through him. He would stammer and well up with tears, believing those impossibly tall men draped in wool and brass could see directly into his soul.
The intervening years had done wonders for his composure. He no longer found himself stricken in the presence of cops. A twinge, a flutter, a fleeting concern—these were all that remained of his childhood agonies. Then, just as quickly, they were gone.
George beamed as he opened the door.
“Detective Fasano, won’t you please come in?”
The detective shook his hand, a bashful grin spreading across his tan features as he entered the foyer. Late fifties, George guessed, but still keeping himself fit. The erratic tufts of white hair were all that gave away his age.
“My apologies for disturbing you this late,” the detective said. “It won’t take long.”
“Anything for the committee,” George replied. “Speaking of which, how’s your lovely wife?”
“Furious to be missing your hospitality, I can tell you. Like I mentioned over the phone—”
“Her sister.”
“Yes.”
George took the man’s overcoat and hat, which dripped rainwater onto the parquet. He suppressed a flash of irritation as he deposited them into the closet. “I’ve got a fire going in the parlor if you’d like to get dry. And there’s a pie cooling in the kitchen. I thought we could have some with our coffee.”
“I wish you hadn’t gone to the trouble.”
“Nonsense, you’ll be doing me a favor. I’m up to my neck in blueberries this time of year.”
The detective withdrew a pack of cigarettes from his breast pocket as he neared the hearth. “All that gardening. I don’t know how you do it, Mr. Babineaux. My back would give out.” He lowered himself onto the chaise. “Do you mind if I smoke?”
“Not at all—and please, call me George. How do you like your coffee?”
“Black is fine.”
George wheeled into the kitchen and took the percolator off the flame. He poured two cups, then removed a knife from the cupboard.
“How are the roses coming?” the detective called out.
“Just put in the compost layer. They’ll need to be fertilized this summer if the blend isn’t right.”
A chuckle came from the other room. “Hard to imagine you getting anything wrong, George.”
George plated the second slice and licked some blueberry filling off his thumb. “There’s a first time for everything, detective.”
He gathered the pies on a tray and returned to the parlor, where the detective spent the next ten minutes briefing him on the town’s upcoming Fourth of July celebration. The mayor wanted to lead the parade in a Cadillac convertible filled with George’s prize-winning roses. The detective’s wife served as parade chairwoman, so it fell to her—or, in this case, her husband—to convince George to make the donation.
“Hmm, the Fourth,” George said. “The rose show will be right on its heels, so that’s cutting it fine. Still, there are always plenty of discards.”
“I’m sure she’ll be grateful for whatever you can spare,” the detective said, his bashful smile returning. It was a nice smile, George decided. He liked how the skin around the man’s eyes crinkled.
The detective scraped up the last of the pie and stubbed out his cigarette. “Do you mind if I use your bathroom?”
George stared at him for a moment, lost in thought.
“George?”
“I’m sorry. Of course you may. That hallway, second door on the left.”
As the detective got to his feet, George felt it once more.
The twinge.
He sipped his coffee and listened as the bathroom door closed.
#
The furnace was on, alright. Bob could feel the heat pouring through. Still, there was no odor. He knelt beside the vent for a closer sniff.
Nothing.
He sat back on his haunches, feeling silly. Silly to be squatting on the floor of George Babineaux’s bathroom on a rainy Wednesday evening. Silly to have taken Jerry’s story at face value.
Jerry Kenna was an old army buddy. They’d served together in the 9th Infantry, first driving the enemy out of Bastogne and later marching deep into the German hinterlands. They were reunited years later when Jerry’s company relocated him to Bergen County. His friend was a hell of a guy, but he drank. Drank to the point where it affected his judgment and memory.
Bob considered this as he recalled the preposterous tip Jerry had phoned in earlier that week. He could still remember the tremor in his buddy’s voice as he relayed the story.
“It was a dinner party,” Jerry began. “Me, the wife, two other couples. All of us invited to George Babineaux’s house. Anyways, we’re between courses, so I excuse myself to take a leak. While I’m in the bathroom, I catch a whiff of this odor coming from the vent. It smelled like…”
“What?” Bob asked.
Jerry made a second attempt, but he couldn’t summon the words. Bob would have grown impatient were he not so amused; his friend was a bull of a man, not easily shaken.
At last Jerry found his nerve.
“It smelled like the spring of forty-five.”
Bob went cold.
“What did you say?”
Jerry repeated it, exactly as before and without elaboration. For some time afterward, the only sound on the telephone line was the rustling of paper clips. Bob was shifting them around his blotter in agitated patterns, letting Jerry’s words sink in. His friend was the first to break the silence.
“I thought, you know, with the disappearances and everything…”
“Jerry, c’mon. Are you sure?”
“I’d never forget that smell.”
Bob hadn’t forgotten it either. In the days following Jerry’s call, his mind went in a thousand directions. The bodies at Buchenwald. The Manson killings on television. And, as Jerry had mentioned, the dozen souls reported missing along the turnpike, each still an unsolved case after six years of investigation. Finally, Bob made a decision. He wanted access to George’s house, but obtaining a warrant was a nonstarter. So he concocted a ruse about the Fourth of July parade.
Now, skulking in George’s bathroom, he wished he hadn’t. There was nothing passing through that grate but the smell of a clean and well-kept home. He was reasonably sure about something else, too. By the time Jerry had stumbled to the toilet that night, he was likely half-crocked on his host’s liquor, which his interpretation of events unreliable.
George had no criminal record. Bob was at his house under false pretenses, eating his food and wasting his evening. It was time to leave the man alone.
He flushed the toilet and ran the faucet before exiting the bathroom. Back in the parlor, George waited dutifully in the same position he’d left him. Bob offered a departing handshake.
“I can’t thank you enough, George.”
George looked crestfallen at the prospect of his leaving. “Won’t you have another cup before you go?”
“It’ll keep me up.”
“Another time, perhaps.”
Bob nodded noncommittally. George led him to the foyer and helped him into his overcoat.
“Where are you parked, detective?”
“On Collier. Your driveway was blocked.”
George rolled his eyes. “The Zweigs. They’re having a shindig. Listen, you’ll get to Collier faster if you follow me out through the back garden. The roses aren’t in bloom, but the camellias—”
“The scenic route.”
“Yes.”
“Alright.”
George grabbed a canvas jacket from the closet and pulled it on. Bob noticed the cuffs were soiled and damp.
“Gardening in the rain tonight?” he asked.
“I always make a final pass before supper, just to check on things. Come, I’ll show you the way.”
An unsettling thought struck Bob as he followed the other man to the back door. Everyone in Saddle River considered George something of an enigma. He was a pillar of the community, with his dinner parties and charitable work, but also strangely removed from it. He had no past, no family. People enjoyed his hospitality but never seemed to get beneath the polite surface, to the man within. That part seemed to belong exclusively to the flowers. They consumed his existence.
The troubling thing was how much the two men had in common. Bob’s wife liked to needle him for being obsessed with his cases, claiming that without her influence—the cookouts, the bowling league—he’d have no relationships at all. He’d never thought much about it until now.
“Watch your step,” George said, holding the screen door.
Bob landed on the raised patio. George led him past a rambling potting shed and onto a path that wound through the flower beds. The garden was impressive, of course. But in twilight it was also dense and mysterious, a murky tract of endless life that filled the air with the primal scents of rot and renewal. It was almost overwhelming to Bob’s nose, and it got stronger as they went.
“And here, detective, my pride and joy.”
George had stopped at a junction where the path forked in two. In the hedge just beyond, a serpentine tangle of leaves, thorns, and calyxes devoured the space. The rosebushes.
As Bob approached them, he could barely keep his dinner from coming up. Fresh compost had an odor, he knew. But this was different.
This smelled like the spring of forty-five.
#
George was surprised by the detective’s reaction. He looked stricken. Well, not everyone is keen on a garden tour in inclement weather. He shouldn’t have troubled the man.
“I’m sorry, detective. You’ll want to be heading home. Collier is just this way—”
“How do you make it, George?”
“Pardon?”
“The compost. How do you make it?”
Suddenly, there it was again. The twinge. George took a deep breath.
“Why do you assume I make it?” he asked, favoring the detective with a coy smile. “Many of the best gardeners use a commercial blend.”
“Listen, George. I’m not the green thumb you are. That goes without saying. But we do tend a little garden of our own—”
“What do you plant?”
“Zinnias, I think. The wife’s hobby.”
“Charming.”
“Anyway, we use the store-bought. And it smells nothing like this.”
“There is an odor,” George replied, wondering where this was going. “And, yes, the formula is my own creation. I applaud your powers of deduction.”
“Comes with the job.”
George smiled, expecting the detective to do likewise. He didn’t. For once, the man regarded him squarely and without any self-effacement.
“You haven’t answered my question, George.”
“I’m sorry?”
“I asked you how you make it.”
A biting wind shot through the garden, rattling the stems. George suppressed a shiver. “During the winter, I produce it in my basement,” he said. “The usual process—a bin, some wire mesh, organic materials. You know, scraps of things.”
“Do you mind if I borrow some?” the detective asked. “For the zinnias—they keep dying on my wife.”
“Well, in that case, perhaps I should create something new for her. Something for annuals—”
“That won’t be necessary. Whatever you’ve got in your basement is fine.”
George felt a hammering in his chest now. “If you’d come earlier this week, maybe we could have arranged something. I just used the last of it.”
“The roses.”
“Yes.”
The detective squinted at the topsoil. “Alright, then,” he said. “Just tell me what it’s made of. When you say scraps—”
“I’m sorry, detective,” George stammered. “That formula is p-proprietary.”
“A secret.”
George nodded.
The detective moved towards him. He didn’t stop until they were nose to nose.
“Nothing makes us so lonely as our secrets, George.”
George didn’t respond. He couldn’t respond. He could barely pull oxygen into his lungs. For the first time since childhood, he sensed lightning bolts in the air, ready to strike him at any moment.
The detective reached into his overcoat and withdrew a tiny manilla envelope.
“I know this is painful for you, George. I wish it didn’t have to be this way.” He turned up the flap and blew into the sleeve. “The problem is, we’re both perfectionists at our jobs. Now, if you’ll please stand back.”
George yielded, allowing the detective a clear path to the rosebushes. The older man dropped a knee and began scooping clumps of soil into the envelope, making little scraping noises as he went. George gritted his teeth. It was the sound of desecration. The opening salvo in an inevitable series of insults, of which scandal and imprisonment concerned him the least. No, the real horror would be standing helpless while his life’s work—the result of his own sacrifice and that of so many others—withered and died in his absence.
Placing a hand in his jacket pocket, he fumbled for the cast-iron trowel he’d used during his last trip to the garden. It was there. He squeezed the handle, transferring all his anguish to the molded grip.
Meanwhile, the detective clicked a ballpoint pen and wrote something on the envelope, as if it were evidence to be logged. Then he withdrew a second sleeve and repeated the process—blowing into the pocket, crouching, gashing the soil.
It was only now, as the irksome scraping resumed, that George noticed the man’s bald spot. A tan bullseye encircled by moonlit white hair.
He gave the trowel a final squeeze as he removed it from his jacket. Lofting it high above his target, he waited a beat longer than necessary, allowing the gods one last chance to smite him. When lightning didn’t come, he swung the iron with all his might.
.
The End
Bio
Frank Vatel is a writer and freelance illustrator whose work has appeared in Reckon Review. He spends far too much time discussing crime fiction and old movies on social media and is currently penning a noir novel set during the Depression. He lives with his wife in Chicago. His handle on Bluesky is @frankvatel312.bsky.social.
More
- Night Shift Politics by Michael Wegener
- Shangri-La by Robert M. Ingram
- Pauli by Matt Gossman
- The Butterfly Collector by Eamonn Furey
- Intoxication by Lynda Williams
Out Now: Transference
“Get ready for an intense ride through the dark and gritty streets of Manchester in this brutal and lyrical crime thriller. As the hedonistic club scene of the 90s rages on, a girl falls to her death from the stage, unnoticed by most. But for John Black, an ex-SAS soldier working security that night, her death will change everything. Now in witness protection after exposing the city’s underworld, he returns to Manchester to help a grieving mother find answers to her son’s suicide. But as he delves deeper into the case, strange recordings hint at a disturbing increase in sexual depravity in the block of flats the boy jumped from. With vengeance on his mind and his own identity at stake, John must confront the orchestrator of his pain and solve the case before it’s too late. This is a story of redemption and revenge, where lyrical poetry mixes with blood on the rain-soaked alleyways of Manchester.”
If you enjoyed James Ellroy’s “The Black Dahlia,” you’ll love this dark and atmospheric novel filled with deceit, depravity, and unexpected twists.


