Share this article

(2558 Words)

The letter John Porter had just decided to write launched him around his kitchen counter to his computer. If my need to contact Meredith is greater than her need not to hear from me, then I have every right to do it. Soon the thin 73-year-old was tapping away at yet another message to the woman he’d had an affair with 48 years before. Despite the fact she hadn’t responded to any but his first few letters, decades back.    

This time will be different, thought Porter, as a chill November front outside drizzled his Rockford windowpanes. He’d talk about the book she wrote 35 years ago he’d just read. It analyzed the Spanish poet Góngora’s “Fable of Polyphemus and Galatea,” Polyphemus being the crude Cyclops who kills the beautiful sea nymph´s lover. Meredith, the short woman whose thick blonde Irish hair had wreathed keenly intelligent blue eyes when he´d last seen her long ago, earned, after their time together, a doctorate in Comparative Literature. Porter found her book by turns scholarly, insightful, and lyrical. All in all, tremendous. He wasn’t the only one. Over a thousand libraries around the world had chosen to shelve it. All those times I took her from behind admiring her butt, only now I get interested in her mind.   

Porter composed his letter over two days. Tweaked it; reflected; tweaked it some more. He kept mostly to her book, but did manage to work in a few words about how he understood why she hadn’t responded to him for so long.

This was owing, he figured, to a certain screw-up of his. Meredith had no doubt recoiled from information about him coming, he imagined, from their mutual friend Joan 38 years before. He´d called Joan one night and wildly confessed to having recently impregnated a Finnish waitress 10 years his junior in Chicago—then planning to leave her. But, he countered to himself, But! Meredith would also know, again through Joan, that the woman in question had miscarried. 

So: how unfair was it on Meredith’s part to hold his planned abandonment against him—since, in the end, there’d been neither a mother nor a child to abandon?   

Still he had to grant he’d probably been too aggressive in the self-defense he´d next sent Meredith amid her deepening silence. Disingenuous as well. 

Here Porter paused at the small wood table he’d painted a sylvan green and yellow at 22 to recall it all again. As he´d done countless times before, every detail the same, over the past 38 years. 

How had it gone? “I’ve had a letter from Joan,” he´d read one morning on a page from Meredith´s trademark yellow legal pad, the six words couched among only a few others. Porter thought long and hard back then too about what to write.

“So you’ve heard from Joan? I haven’t been in touch with her for quite a while. How is she?” Of course he’d known damn well how Joan was from his phone call to her—which, again, Meredith had no doubt heard about straight from the woman herself. What a blunder! And yes: Joan surely wrote Meredith about his confession as well. How could a news item like that go unshared between friends?

Meredith didn´t reply to that long-ago letter.   

So Porter had written another. This time he acknowledged the Finnish waitress. He said his conscience was clear because she herself had granted him her forgiveness. He didn’t need anyone else’s, he added. Including Meredith’s.  

Silence.      

Understandable, I guess, thought Porter, as the months, then years, unspooled. But—couldn’t she get over it? With time? His planned abandonment of the Finnish young woman, his lie about Joan, his aggressiveness with Meredith herself? Wasn’t forgiveness the cardinal virtue? Wasn’t she—the bright-eyed one with the quicksilver mind, his hungry lover in bed (“straight as a dollar bill,” a disappointed lesbian once said of her)—a virtuous person? 

The years rolled by in Porter’s life like empty boxcars in an endless train. After Meredith he´d dated from time to time, including the Finn, but no one remotely compared to his vital one. He´d visited strip clubs and brothels too, though those experiences also declined to zero. Back when he´d finally given up on higher education, just after his time with Meredith, Porter took the work an employment agency offered him—calculating fire insurance premiums. It paid his rent and filled his stomach but in other respects left him cold. Still, he defended his increasingly antiquated employment perch from encroaching algorithms by negotiating a deal with his compassionate boss to sell, on the side, a certain low amount of the company´s insurance monthly. In this way Porter passed the bulk of his life in financial precarity alone.    

              But there had lately risen in him a North Star: the notion of renewed contact with his extraordinary one. For years, thinking about Meredith had made Porter uncomfortable. Thus he hadn´t much. But when he did, it seemed to him to have something to do with an unformed person dealing with a formed one. Meredith had journaled almost daily to define what she valued, what she believed, and why she felt what she felt. Porter, on the other hand, as indolent as Meredith was industrious, defined himself by default: whatever others took him to be, he wasn´t. This he´d seen as the way to preserve his freedom, the crown jewel of which was his right to exit any context at any time for any reason he might or might not choose to disclose. Meredith would sometimes say, when she sounded him about his future and he failed to reply with anything substantial—or at times even coherent—“I don´t understand you!” Porter secretly thrilled to these words. They showed him that, by turning Socrates on his head, he´d guaranteed his freedom. Know thyself? Porter did not know and had no intention of knowing himself. Because who else could know, and so control, even the self-unknown?  

One afternoon in her living room, after their 15 months together, his lover pressed Porter more urgently about the future. He´d still barely thought about it. But this time, feeling cornered, at long last, it seemed necessary to say something—anything—and it had to hang together. He then heard coming out of his mouth things he´d vaguely guessed he might think, if he did think—which he had not—about his, or their, future. He said he wanted his own children. 

Meredith replied that could not happen with her. In her mid-thirties, pursuing her Master´s, already with two children, it would be too much. But could not Porter consider that her kids were at an age—nine and eleven—when they could be richly enjoyed while no longer requiring the candle and care of infants and toddlers? No, said Porter. (He´d dived in, he had to plunge on.) He wanted his own. Also he wanted to travel. Porter hadn´t thought about that either. 

“You know you´re tearing it? You do know that?” Meredith asked him. 

Porter said nothing. He´d frozen, stunned by what he´d just heard himself say. The only part of his mind still working told him he should look resolute—like a man who knew what he was about.  

Meredith sat on her blue sofa several beats longer than she felt were called for, watching him. She did so on the tiny chance—crumbling instant by instant—that the young man she´d taken such an extended chance on, given her all to, would, even now, it still wasn´t too late, unlock his soul and share it with her. Instead an immobile set of confused features trying to disguise themselves as masculine strength stared back at her. Rising, she said what, more and more in recent months, deep in the hollows of some of her solo nights, she feared she´d have to say to him one day. That day had come.

“Then I will tear you out of my heart.” She left the room. There followed a graceless denouement of a few weeks in which Porter hung around her house, indecisively standing in doorways, neither coming in nor going out, knowing that he had in fact torn it but hoping for more sex anyway.

The Porter at 26, he couldn´t help feeling at 73, had possessed every chance to grow into himself with the help of a superb relationship (they´d also talked books, on the rare occasions he´d read the good ones she´d read) with a magnificent woman. That he had not done so amounted to a failure so irrational, so profound, that Porter feared only a flaw in his very nature could account for it. That explanation was too much to bear. So he found another.  

He hadn´t failed. The game was not up. Meredith would give him another chance. 

At a party one night in a friend´s dim living room done in tan and bronze, standing next to a slender young Afro-American artist he didn’t know, the two holding glasses of burgundy, Porter, to break the ice, apropos of nothing, conjured Meredith. 

“I found her new place. Public records. Old house sold for x, new one bought for y, street address provided—it’s all online. Looked it up on Google Earth. Quite the manse, in the middle of its own little wood. As if she were hiding in there. I won’t go.” 

A strained smile appeared on the artist’s face. 

“Wouldn’t help anything. Could though.” 

A flash of fear. 

“Nah. I won’t. But anyway, it’s nice to know where she’s at. In case—things change.”

The artist said he was going to get his wife a drink and disappeared.

 Porter sent his latest letter snail mail from his grimy apartment out through the cold and gray. He had no idea if Meredith had ever gone online. This missive indeed featured a critique of her book, a careful and generous one. He sent a second printout to her former house as well, just in case, because the cheap automated private detective service he’d selected had told him, impossibly it seemed, that she´d moved back there. 

Porter leaned back in his chair to remember the place. The little house where we had all that great sex. Almost a hobbit-house, that one, wreathed in ivy on its little rise from a narrow sidewalk beside a narrow street extending like a nave under old vaulting trees. He´d climbed the steps of her Tudor brick home often and eagerly to spend yet another night with his marvelous one. Their first together, she’d ridden him in low light, peering with such intense interest at him he’d felt uneasy. Porter passed days as well in the hobbit-house with his excellent girlfriend and her two children throughout their affair nearly fifty years ago. The girl, the younger child, never trusted him. But the boy adored him. Porter took him fishing several times.

Pete is 57 now. Seated at his summery table in the Rockford drizzle, the man who had never had his own children nor traveled shook his head as if repelling a fly.    

Winter descended on his dreary den. Nothing arrived from Meredith.           

Time, as it drained out of Porter´s solitary existence in uniform monotony, at last worked a change in the bald and wasting man. He felt it first in his gut. A slight pain, which sharpened at thoughts of Meredith.

Why wouldn´t she write him? Hadn´t he explained everything about the young Finn? Hadn´t he read, evaluated, and sincerely praised Meredith´s book? He´d written her a letter in Spanish, a language they shared, along the way. Sent her a book of essays he thought she´d like. And a subscription to Scientific American, that she might find analogues in the natural world for her poetic conceits, for she wrote in that form too. 

It isn´t fair. She had no right to end the last trace of them, the correspondence he cherished. Needed. Required. Especially when she could see he´d been trying so hard to set things right. 

Fuck no it isn´t fair! Insulting is what it was. Maybe even sadistic. Did she enjoy the pain she was causing him as she scanned letter after desperate letter, smiling a little as she walked them to the glowing fireplace her regal new mansion-in-a-wood doubtless included? The pain in Porter´s gut grew worse. As he continued to brood over her through the following weeks, sometimes he trembled with rage. 

As December deepened outside his kitchen window he sold no insurance, nor had he sold enough in November. Dirty dishes lingered in his sink. He showered less. Hardly anyone phoned. Nor did he call out. What was the point? Only one thing had come to matter: the grave wrong being done him. 

Which, he realized, one cold and empty Sunday, could have a consequence. It was simple symmetry, was it not? Action, reaction.  Or no action, action. His gut flared. 

He picked up Meredith´s book from his Monet table from happier times and opened it to a couple of bookmarked pages. These he reread from the new perspective he´d recently been entertaining. Namely, that he´d been wrong all this time. Meredith had written him back. On certain pages of her book.  

“Desire draws the Cyclops from his cave, and his appearance on earth will wrench earth into a world whose gods are terrorized into withdrawal—withdrawal from his inexorable drive towards debasement and disfigurement.” Are you talking about me, Meredith?

“It is a shifting processional of points of light which Polyphemus begins to discern in his mirage of Galatea, as he hovers on the boundary of his monstrosity, gazing, like Caliban, into a more spacious world.” So I´m a monster, Meredith?   

“The eros of the Cyclops is directed to a being of superior order in nature.” Which would be you?

Porter sat motionless a long while, his breath coming short.

Bitch! 

At length, an idea formed. Since he was Polyphemus, why not rouse himself and emerge from his dingy cave? Go look for Galatea? 

Because how stupid of anyone to imagine he would—or could—ever let her go. How stupid squared of the extraordinary one who thought she knew him so well. She who´d once found him worthy of her interest. Her body. Even her love. But who now pretended to care not a whit about him.  

Well, Meredith… I think you´ll find you do care. When you hear a sound downstairs. When you squint in the dark and make me out standing next to your fireplace looking towards the ashes of all my letters you burned, black and cold under the black night leaves of your lonely little forest. Or maybe you´ll turn a corner in your bright upstairs hallway, and there I´ll be: the Cyclops, waiting for you by your bedroom door! Oh, I think you´ll care then. And wish you´d treated a guy better who… needed you to… save him. One last chance, Meredith.    

Adrenaline shot Porter towards his laptop for Google Maps to show him the fastest way to what hope survived in what little remained of his future: to Meredith, 80 if she still drew breath. Once past her shock, he´d make sure she recalled how good they´d been together. As his gaunt form snatched his car keys he noticed through the filmy window over the sink that the short winter day was dying into darkness. He smiled. 

 I always liked it better with the lights off anyway.     

~

The End 


Bio

From Walla Walla, Washington, USA, now living in Mexico City, Mexico, Daniel Bailey (FB Daniel Bailey) has spent half his life in Europe, Polynesia, Asia and Latin America. He’s worked on a tramper in Bristol Bay, Alaska, packed Christmas trees outside Missoula, Montana, and taught 20 years at a university inside a gathering Venezuelan dictatorship.
His narrative nonfiction and essays have appeared in Apple In The Dark Journal, CafeLit, CP Quarterly, El Portal Literary Journal, Star 82 Review, The Garfield Lake Review, The South Shore Review, Willows Wept Review, and elsewhere. Chess and tennis have enriched nearly all his life.


More


Share this article