If it was country, Billy liked it, but Johnny Cash headed up the list. He remembered June Carter Cash dying and knowing that Johnny wouldn’t be far behind. Those next few months he listened to him more than ever, but it was like there was a hushed background of mourning behind every song. It was like watching an old hound you’d had since he was a pup start to piss and shit everywhere and struggle to stand up. You knew it wouldn’t be long till you’d have to take him behind the barn and put a bullet through his brain.
But Johnny had died years ago. Now there was only the music.
Even so, Billy didn’t know how many times he could listen to “Why Do You Punish Me.”
“Mind changing the song, Jessi?” he called out.
His head throbbed. Too much whiskey the night before.
He heard the toilet flush and the bathroom door open.
“Jessi?”
He heard her damn Freebird boots clacking on the floor. Sexy but noisy as hell.
. . .
He’d first laid eyes on her in the produce section in the Winn Dixie. Billy knew his fruits and vegetables, but a good-looking woman in the produce section didn’t need to know that. She hadn’t been wearing boots. She was wearing running shoes and she looked like a runner: long and lean, the curve of her calves outlined clear as day by her blue jeans, so tight that he figured she’d had to lie on her back to wiggle into them. A white T-shirt with SWEET HOME ALABAMA in crimson over her breasts. He pushed his cart past to get a good look.
Her hair, tied back in a pony tail that ended between her shoulder blades, was light brown, but the pony tail had streaks of different colors in it: shades of red, green, and blue that she and the hairdresser would know the names of. He wondered how hairdressers could get it so the colors were only in the pony tail. He thought that if he ever dated a hairdresser, she’d be sure to tell him. He’d had a girlfriend who worked in a nail salon and could do crazy shit on nails: the Norman Rockwell Four Freedoms paintings, or Washington Crossing the Delaware. She’d talked on and on about her “craft,” which was why Billy had got tired of her despite her mastery of other “crafts” that he was pretty sure Norman Rockwell had never made a painting of and George Washington had never given a speech about. Anyway, the streaks were sexy.
She was taking a long time with the tomatoes. He thought, I could tell you everything there is to know about tomatoes in less time than you’ve stood there. But he decided to go at her the tried and true way.
He paused in front of the parsley and cilantro.
“I can never tell the difference between—” he started, stopping when she rolled her eyes.
He wasn’t going to give up that easy.
“I’ll get some of everything,” he said. “They’re all healthy, right?”
She was looking at the tomatoes like her eyes could X-ray them.
“Bet you know all about healthy,” he said. “Can tell by looking at you. You a runner?”
She chose a tomato.
“I’m a runner with a husband.”
He dropped a handful of parsley and a handful of cilantro in his cart.
“Don’t see a ring,” he said.
“I was in the garden.”
He held up his hands.
“Not wearing mine either,” he said. “Also in the garden earlier. Easy to forget afterwards.”
She arched an eyebrow.
“You’re married?” she said.
“That so surprising? I look like someone no woman would have?”
Billy grinned, knowing that he looked like someone any woman would have in the right circumstances. The point was to find the circumstances, or create them.
“She told me to pick the dessert tonight,” he said.
He pushed his cart toward the fruits.
“We were talking about healthy, so maybe some fresh fruit. No processed sugar.”
He gripped a pair of cantaloupes. He brought them up to his chest and hefted them. She arched her eyebrow again. He set the cantaloupes down. He went over to the peaches.
“But a little processed sugar’s all right. My wife makes the best peach pie.”
He raised a peach to his mouth.
“She doesn’t feel like baking, we’ll eat them this way. Perfect size for your mouth.”
He looked at the SWEET HOME ALABAMA. She was fine with small breasts.
“This is Dixie,” she said. “What makes her peach pie different?”
“Special recipe from her grandmother.”
He showed her his phone.
“Give me your number, I’ll text you the recipe.”
She smiled one of those fake smiles like airplane stewardesses have.
“Put your number in, could be one you make up and I never see you again,” he said. “Or put your real number in and get a recipe for a peach pie that’s to die for, like they say.”
She shrugged.
“Well, if it’s her grandmother’s recipe. . .”
. . .
So it had begun.
Jessi hadn’t been surprised that Billy had no wife. As for her, she loved her husband because he was a good man. But he was dull. Tom worked at the Alabama State Port Authority and as often as he’d explained what he did, her eyes had always crossed with boredom. And he was pushing forty so the office work showed in his body. Jessi had got him a gym membership. He’d gone a few times to please her, but he said he was embarrassed. She said don’t be, it’ll take time before you start to feel and look better. He’d given up, though.
Billy was different: a firefighter who’d volunteered to go to Southern California for the training that qualified him for “hotshot” crews that fought the worst wildfires in the driest states. Lying beside him, Jessi would squeeze his muscles and finger his scars.
“That’s dangerous work,” she’d say. “You sure you want to keep doing it?”
He would say, “Going to do it as long as I can because I’m saving lives.”
For Jessi, that summed it up: Tom was a good man while Billy was a hero.
But Tom was her lawfully wedded husband: to have and to hold for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish, till death did them part. She figured she shouldn’t spice things up with Billy for too long or Tom would find out.
Although Billy living out in the country with no neighbors around gave her some latitude in deciding what “too long” meant.
. . .
As a few weeks turned into a few months Jessi started thinking it might be harder to give up the spice Billy provided than to give up her husband.
After making love, Jessi and Billy would listen to music. Her tastes ran more to rock than his did, but she loved Johnny Cash. She just didn’t have his whole catalogue memorized like Billy did. It was Billy who introduced her to “Why Do You Punish Me.”
His bed didn’t have a headboard, only a frame to fasten one to if you wanted to do it right. When “Why Do You Punish Me” came on, Billy would get out of bed singing the first line: “Why do you punish me for loving you?” He would kneel on the floor and wrap his hands around the bars of the frame and try to stick his face between them. He would look pitiful and sing along: “My heart cries out behind these prison bars.”
He would say, “You can laugh, but even though it’s you locked into your marriage, it feels like I’m the one behind bars because I can’t have what I want.”
“If there’s any busting out of prison to be done it’s on me,” she would say, not laughing.
. . .
A few months had turned into a year when Jessi told her husband about her carrying on.
Tom teared up but said, “I forgive you, you’re only human.”
“Not asking to be forgiven,” she said. “Telling you because I’m leaving.”
He had just walked in the door after work.
He said, “Let me sit down,” and headed for the kitchen.
Telling him had been hard for Jessi, so she needed a minute. When she got to the kitchen he was sitting and staring straight ahead, tie knotted and jacket on.
“You want a drink? Beer? Wine? Whiskey? Tell me what you want.”
“What I want is you,” he said. “You’re all I ever wanted.”
Which killed her because he was a good man. But there was no going back because now the truth was out. And even though it hurt her to see Tom hurt, she was happy he knew because she wanted Billy. She wanted Billy so much that it was easy to get close to Tom and put her arms around him because it wouldn’t mean what it meant with Billy. She wasn’t worried about getting pulled into making love to him and saying she would stay after all. She only put her arms around him to say he’d find somebody else.
While he blubbered she thought about Billy. After Tom stopped she would drive her packed car to his place. It was six of one, half a dozen of the other to take her car or Billy’s truck, but she was going to insist on her car. Not moving her things out of her trunk would save time. She wanted to get to Pensacola, where she and Billy had three nights ahead of them in a hotel just a hop, skip, and a jump away from the best beach in Florida, with sand like sugar and warm water you could stay in all day long until you went back to your room to make love on those clean hotel sheets and soft pillows.
The last thing Jessi did before abandoning her husband was bring him the Johnnie Walker from the liquor cabinet. He couldn’t tell Scotch apart from bourbon or rye and he couldn’t tell Johnnie Walker apart from other Scotches. But he liked the bottle. He liked the picture of the man in old-fashioned clothes and high boots and holding a walking stick.
. . .
A few weeks after Pensacola, Billy and Jessi still felt like they were honeymooning until she said she was pregnant. They knew the baby was Tom’s: the dates Billy had been away fighting a fire proved it.
“Tom and I prayed on getting pregnant but never could,” Jessi told Billy. “I think the doctors were right to say I was the problem, but they didn’t understand what was blocking me. My body didn’t have the passion to reproduce until you got me excited.”
Billy was less interested in Jessi’s crazy idea about where the baby had come from than where she was going with it.
“So as far as I’m concerned the baby never needs to know that Tom’s his daddy,” she said.
“Fine, don’t tell Tom,” Billy said. “But no baby’s ever going to think I’m his daddy.”
Jessi had hoped Billy would take it differently.
“Getting rid of that thing’ll be hard in this state,” he said. “But California has doctors who act like it’s Christmas morning when a woman asks for an abortion.”
That made Jessi angry.
She said, “I’m having the baby.”
Billy said, “It’ll change things between us.”
But he could see she was dug in so he needed to change the mood.
He got out of bed crooning “Why do you punish me for loving you,” pressing his face into the bars of the headboard frame and continuing, “My heart cries out behind these prison bars.”
. . .
The next week, Jessi refused to comply with Billy’s request for sex. She was suffering from morning sickness. They got into a bad argument. That night she lost the baby. He said he was sorry about what had happened but she didn’t see sorry in his eyes. The next day when Billy got called to California to fight a wildfire, she decided that the break would do both of them good.
She was still feeling poorly when she heard that Tom, most likely on his way to the University of South Alabama campus where he’d fallen in love with Jessi—this hopeless visit encouraged by excess consumption of Johnnie Walker, habitual since her departure—had driven through a red light near campus and been struck and killed by a pickup truck.
. . .
Jessi liked “Why Do You Punish Me,” especially the line about the prison bars. She had considered it Billy’s song, but after the miscarriage it became her song.
Billy understood what that meant on the morning he found himself listening to “Why Do You Punish Me” over and over again. The night before he’d returned from California, where the fire had almost killed him.
Jessi had said, “That’s the last wildfire you’ll ever fight.”
“There are still lives to save,” he said.
Jessi felt differently now about Billy saving lives and being a hero.
He was sipping whiskey. Jessi lowered her voice to a whisper even though they were alone.
“Don’t have too much, you know what I mean.”
. . .
In the morning he remembered the sex. But the pleasure faded as Johnny Cash started in on “Why Do You Punish Me” for the tenth time.
He’d ignored Jessi’s caution about the whiskey. He had kept his eyes shut because of his headache. Now he opened them. He saw he wasn’t in his bedroom. He knew by the unfinished ceiling he was in the cellar. He wondered why there was a bed there.
He heard her boots on the concrete floor. He sat up and saw the bars with her on the other side. The two sides of bars and the two sides of wall in the corner of the cellar formed a rectangle just big enough to hold the bed they had shared the night before.
“Didn’t know I was handy, did you?” she said.
“Let me out, Jessi.”
She smiled.
“Not certain there’s a Heaven and Hell, Billy. But if there is, you’ll be in the wrong place to see Tom or his baby.”
She started to walk away. She stopped and turned around.
“Guess what I’m doing means you’ll see me in Hell. But I plan to get there long after you. Not so good for you, living out in the country.”
She pointed to the laptop on the floor, plugged into the wall beyond his reach.
“Got your song to listen to till the end of time. More time than you’ll need.”
She walked to the stairs and climbed them while Billy screamed and Johnny Cash sang.
THE END
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Don Stoll’s notorious crimes include overstaying a tourist visa for the UK. He lives in Southern California and his stories–often based on the portion of his young manhood misspent in England after overstaying that visa–have appeared in BRISTOL NOIR, PUNK NOIR, CLOSE TO THE BONE, HORLA, and elsewhere.
In 2008, Don and his wife founded their nonprofit (karimufoundation.org) which continues to bring new schools, clean water, and medical clinics to a cluster of remote Tanzanian villages.
Follow Don on Twitter: @DonStoll3
