The eyes. It’s all in the eyes. Always. I had a buddy on the force, his kid got cancer. Leukemia. Six years old. After the kid died, guy had the same kind of eyes. More than sad. Glazed over. Desolate. Kind of eyes you gaze into and know there are more ways to kill a person than stopping their heartbeat. Both the Leweks stared at me now with those eyes. Made me tighten my jaw, concentrate on the patterns twisting on the wallpaper. I needed a drink. More than that I needed the cash money. Credit cards maxed out a month ago and at the point of counting pocket change. I cleared my throat, took out the small notebook and ballpoint pen I carried in my breast pocket, holding them awkwardly in my palsied hand, waiting for the couple to go on. Mrs. Lewek placed her fingers gently to the photograph on the dining table between us again, licked at her thin lips, “we just want to know where she is. So, we can bring her home. She should be at home with us,” she nodded at me.
I gazed down at the creased, dogeared photograph of the girl. If I hadn’t already had known I would have guessed her age wrong. Kid looked like she could’ve been fifteen, but her mother said she was a mature twelve. Denim dungarees. Hair pulled into an absent-minded ponytail. Squinting with the sun on her face. Real cute kid. I wondered what my own grandkids looked like nowadays. The eldest would have been in high school, the youngest just finishing elementary. Probably. The memories I had of them, and my daughter were a long time ago and a long way away. I wiped a fist across my forehead. I needed a Goddamned drink.
Mr. Lewek placed his left hand over his wife’s and squeezed, “we read about the troubles you had on the force all those years ago. Googled you, to be frank. Just so you know, we don’t give a shit about any of that. As far as I’m concerned you were dealt a bad hand. Alison agrees. We’ve heard what you do… We just want to have our baby back and…” his voice wavered and trailed off. I clicked the ballpoint pen a couple of times and gave him time to go on. He didn’t and his wife readjusted the photograph and carried on for him.
“We waited for the police. Waited and waited. All we seem to have been doing is waiting, waiting, waiting, waiting. We don’t want to waste any more time. That’s what the police have been so far, a big fat waste of time. They want us to just accept that our baby is gone. Another one of those cold cases. Barely five years later… She’d be seventeen years old now. Getting ready for college. Talking about boys and getting into trouble for staying out too late,” those shimmering eyes like broken water danced over the photograph and then flickered up to rest on mine, suddenly burning intently. “We don’t care how you do it. You could burn the entire county to ash for all we care but please, bring our baby home? Will you bring her home to us? Please.”
I said I would try my best. They paid me in cash. I left with a scanned copy of the photograph of the kid and the still empty notebook in my breast pocket. Drove straight to the nearest Seven Eleven, bought myself a fifth of whiskey and a pack of cigarettes. Sitting in the parking lot, nipping at the bottle, and thumbing through the internet on my smartphone for old articles related to the case. Making notes of names and places. The same ones kept coming up again and again. The cops had really screwed the case. Multiple times. Illegal searches. Coercion of witnesses. The Feds, Sheriffs Department and the State Police squabbling over media coverage. Evidence thrown out of court. It was a shitshow from start to finish. The Leweks suffered throughout it all. Scandal Rags and Internet Trolls accusing them, all kinds of horrendous bullshit.
Hours later with the fifth gone, in my eyes it was an open and shut case. I tossed the phone on the passenger seat, looking at the photograph of the missing girl and holding the empty bottle in a grip that was too tight. Catching my eyes in the rear-view I knew I was attempting to quench a thirst and a sadness that would never soften or quit. Or die.
Technology had made the jobs of people like myself real easy and it wasn’t long before I located the address and the directions of where I needed to be. Spent a day driving out there and the following couple of days staking the place out. The end of a quiet suburban street. A non-descript, small house with peeling blue paint, an overgrown yard and a busted screen door leaning up against the side of the exterior. At night, the ghostly light from a television crawled from the upstairs window out into the darkness. In the daytime, if I wound down my window, I could hear the cackling canned laughter of the same television. No one came. No one went. The flag on the mailbox stayed down. The street was dead. A place for ghosts. I whiled the time away, emptying more bottles of fifth and using them to piss in. Neck stiffer than a five-day-old corpse. Avoiding my reflection in the mirror.
In the early hours of the fourth day, I drove out to a deserted rest stop on the highway, took a shit and made myself vomit by sticking my fingers down my throat. Clear headed, I moved the sports bag and the bulletproof vest from the trunk to the front passenger seat, going through everything again. Checking, rechecking by torchlight. Switched off my phone, pushed it under the seat and drove right on back. Parked outside the shitbird’s house, pulled the vest over my head, and took the .45 I’d held to my own head more than a few times, from the kitbag.
The television set still on, lighting up the weed-filled drive in a supernatural glow as I made my way quickly up the overgrown lawn. Around the back, the door was open. I slipped the lock picks back into my pocket and let myself in real slow. The hinges squeaking audibly freezing me up momentarily. The kitchen-cum-living room reeked of sweat, ammonia and fried food. The flashlight flashed over filth. Pornography magazines and comic books strewn around. A shit encrusted dildo on the coffee table next to a few Budweiser bottles. Keeping the pistol and torch held at shoulder height I made my way quickly down the hall and up the stairs. Stepping on the edge of every step to avoid creaking wood. The handles of the bag cutting into my shoulder. The bedroom door was open and illuminated by the pulsing of a television screen.
He was sprawled naked on the bed covered by a crusty bath towel. Bald and fat. Spectacles crooked on his too smooth face and reflecting Fox News. Mouth agape and drooling. He hadn’t changed at all since the mugshots. I shined the flashlight in his face and dropped the sports bag down heavy on the end of the bed. He startled awake, high-pitched muttering. Readjusting the glasses on his pink bowling ball of a head and glaring at me with small eyes as sentimental as bottlecaps and then down the muzzle of the gun pointed at his pregnant-looking gut.
“There’s nothing here worth stealing. No drugs neither. You better get out of here before I call the cops,” he whined in a rancid treacle-laced southern accent.
I told him to shut his mouth and put his hands on his head. He did and I swatted a pile of clothes from a short stool and pulled it close to the bed. Sat down. The gun on him the entire time. He started to say something else, and I cut him off with a wave of the .45.
“Your name is James Michaels.”
It wasn’t a question, but he nodded the affirmative in slow motion like a man finally understanding the punch line to a joke told to him at a party a week before.
“What do you want?” he said, voice a dry whisper now, eyes bouncing from my face to the gun to the bag to the bedroom door.
I told him to turn on the lamp on the bedside table and he pulled the thin chain lighting up the room, blinking away the shocking change in light. I waved the barrel at his obese gut one more time. He nodded quick, slapped his small hands back on top of his dome.
I unzipped the bag, taking out each utensil and showing it to him before placing it carefully in front of me on the stained bedsheets. A bone saw, a scalpel, a small blowtorch, and a ballpoint hammer. His eyes very wide and the hands on his head sending tremors of violent shakes down his sweat shiny forearms to his elbows. The last thing I took out to show him was the photograph of the girl from my breast pocket. His eyes flashed bright and then he started shaking his head from side to side.
“Keep your hands on your head and your mouth shut. Cooperate and this will go quickly and smoothly. I’ll disappear as quickly as I arrived. Do you understand? Nod your head if you do,” I said, changing the .45 to my left hand to give my right arm a break. He nodded yes and I continued, “I’m going to summarise to save us both time. In March of 2016 you stalked and then snatched a little girl named Katie Lewek as she walked home from band practice. Probably using a cloth soaked in chloroform to knock her out but details like that don’t much matter now. You dragged her into the white Ford pickup truck you owned then, drove somewhere isolated, raped and murdered her. Fled the state to this shithole.”
“You a cop? I already been acquitted of all that,” he smirked.
I nodded, “Yes, I used to be and yes, you have. But not by me and I’m the only person in the world that matters right now. Dogs picked up the scent of a corpse in the Ford you sold soon after and forensics found traces of the little girls DNA on the backseat of said truck.”
“All ruled inconclusive. Thrown out of court. The cops were corrupt. Besides, they say that little girl ran away from home. Never found a body. She’s probably selling her little coochie at some truck stop,” he smiled a yellow-tainted, shit-eating grin.
I pulled on a pair of plastic surgical gloves, followed by a map and a few sheets of A4 paper from the bag and tossed them at him. Fumbled around inside the bag a moment. Put a hand behind my back. Got up and walked to the side of the bed so I was looming over him. He shifted away from me slightly and jutted his chin at the map and paper.
“What you want me to do? Write a confession? Like that would ever mean a damn thing in a court of law anyway.”
“No, you’re going to tell me where the little girl is buried. Where you put her body. Her parents want her back. Buried proper.”
He chuckled but his eyes slit like blades, “not a fucking chance in hell.”
I sucked my teeth; it was the kind of response I’d expected. The kind of response I’d been hoping for. I slammed the rag of chloroform over his mouth and nose and pushed his head down hard into the mattress.
When he regained consciousness the third time, blood dribbling from around the ball gag in his mouth, I was drenched in sweat tying the last of the tourniquets around his flabby calf. He squealed and struggled weakly on the piss, shit and blood puddled plastic tarpaulin. The stumps where his lower legs and feet had been waving around ridiculously. The stench of cauterised flesh choking. I placed the map and some fresh paper in front of him. He gazed at me with eyes that were desolate. Broken. Mrs. Lewek flashed through my mind. Finally, he nodded. I cut the plastic ties binding his wrist. The .45 to the back of his skull.
I was in a bar a week later watching the news. The Leweks were speaking into a microphone at a press conference. The volume too low, and the jukebox too loud. I didn’t know what they were saying. Their eyes still desolate but there was a mournful, heartbroken relief there as well. The manhunt for James Michaels was ongoing. I raised my glass in salute to the television screen knowing one hundred percent it always would be. Authorities had more chance of finding Jimmy Hoffer. I waved the bartender over, ordered another drink, waiting for the next job or the end of my bankroll. Whichever came first.
THE END
ABOUT STEPHEN J. GOLDS
Stephen J. Golds was born in North London, U.K, but has lived in Japan for most of his adult life.
He writes primarily in the noir and dirty realism genres and is the co-editor of Punk Noir Magazine. He enjoys spending time with his daughters, reading books, traveling the world, boxing and listening to old Soul LPs.
His novels are Say Goodbye When I’m Gone, I’ll Pray When I’m Dying, Always the Dead, Poems for Ghosts in Empty Tenement Windows I Thought I Saw Once and the story and poetry collection Love Like Bleeding Out With an Empty Gun in Your Hand.
