I’ve only known two murderers. One of them, the one I could barely call an acquaintance, went to medical school and smiled all the time. Our interactions brief, always pleasant, and always forgettable, just like his name.
The other insisted on being called Colt. He wouldn’t answer to anything else. We were close, at least for a short time. I wonder if he still considers me a friend.
Where did I even meet Colt?
The exact location is hard to place—there were crowds of sombre people pretending to be happy. It could’ve as easily been a drunken orgy as a church service. There was plenty of laughter, but each throaty bark had undertones of smouldering rage, each clap on the back made with a closed fist. We were all doing our part in stretching our last bit of sanity across the room, like an abused elastic, waiting, hoping, it would snap. Then, freedom. Freedom and an infinite excuse.
My memory, it’s ragged.
These are not people who settle quietly in the mind, but primal forces that rage through grey canals and dance and shift until the memories become more vibrant than the lives they were born from. More than this is the curse of their single defining act; it rings so loud that their entire existence coalesces, blends into a muted colour that ceases to matter in the harsh light of what they have done. It’s not fair. It’s not fair at all. Nothing is, if broken down to its most basic elements.
I do remember seeing him for the first time.
His limbs put me in mind of barbwire. His eyes had a strange shine. Those two silver flecks combed the room, looking for something to break.
And Amber, a calculating, fierce woman whom we all loved and feared, clung to his arm. I heard several hearts break at the sight of her with this stranger. It sounded like a succession of snapping bones.
“Everyone,” Amber said. “Meet Colt.”
“Colt?” someone shouted. “Like a baby horsey?”
Someone neighed. A few people laughed.
“No,” Colt said. “Nothing like that.”
The laughter suffocated under his tone. Was there a tear tattooed below his eye or was it just a trick of our collective unease? I had an epiphany, a prophetic vision of fingers flexing over a holster carrying death.
“Colt,” I said. “Like the gun.”
He swivelled toward me. I thought he was going to take a swing. But he just stared. I’ll never know what facets of me he was weighing, what he found worthy and what he found wanting, only that the scales balanced in my favour.
His lips tugged upward—an evil crescent.
“That’s right,” Colt said. “Goddamn right.”
I spent the rest of the evening with Colt and Amber. I liked being liked by people who were considered dangerous. Maybe you understand.
*
It turns out there wasn’t a teardrop tattooed below his eye—not yet. What I had mistaken for ink was a small purple mark that looked like a cross between a bruise and a wart. Colt would finger it every so often, usually when he was debating whether or not to destroy something.
In these moments, it was Amber who kept him in check.
But Amber was at work. We were alone in her apartment.
“Here,” Colt said. “My namesake.”
The gun was heavier than it looked, and it looked heavy. What else can I say? It had an ivory-handled grip and gleamed silver and it belonged on the set of a western. The only thing I knew about guns was that you were supposed to get as far away from them as possible.
“It’s not going to bite,” Colt said. “Give it.”
The gun left my hands. Thunder crash.
I don’t remember leaping behind the couch, but when my ears stopped ringing I realized I was hugging the carpet. Laughter followed, the edged kind with no humour.
I sprung to my feet. The defining details hit me in a staccato cascade: smoke drifting upward from a silver barrel. The smell of something burning—hair, maybe, or plastic. A fresh crater in the far wall. The bullet hole was bigger than I imagined it’d be.
“You fucking idiot!”
He grinned, put the gun to his nostrils and sucked up the smoke. I almost told him it wasn’t a toy, just like my parents had told me whenever firearms were romanticized on television or in the movies. But how could I? I had treated the whole of my existence as a toy.
“Your turn,” Colt said.
“Fuck that.”
“Your turn,” he repeated.
“Fuck you.”
“Your turn.”
He knew. He knew I wanted the chance to be something more than I was, even if that something was impish and juvenile.
“No,” Colt said. “Hold it with both hands.”
My arms quivered to keep the thing level. I didn’t like the way it felt. I didn’t hate it either. I yanked the trigger. My arms flew behind my head. The bullet went high. I put a hand to my ear to check for blood. My fingers came away clean.
I fired again.
We took turns putting holes in the wall. I expected the cops to show up. They never did, and that was a defeat, not for us, but for the people who were supposed to care.
Eventually, Colt got tired of target practice and packed up his namesake. He disappeared into the kitchen and came back with two tall glasses filled with a clear fluid that wasn’t water. We drank. He told me stories, tales of deceit and violence and riches ill-gotten and ill-gotten riches lost, and no matter how much I wanted to believe them I couldn’t. The small part of me clinging to the charade of the day to day wouldn’t let me.
Colt convulsed on the floor, mumbled something about finding it, finding it soon, and crawled on his belly to the kitchen. When he came back, he told me we were out of liquor. When he had tried to pour himself a fresh drink, most of the liquid had missed the glass.
The door opened. It was Amber. Colt sprung to his feet. I tried to raise my hand in greeting, but I gave up—gravity had gotten worse. Gravity was always screwing me over. I tried a verbal greeting. It came out garbled, so I sat still in hopes that she wouldn’t notice me. It seemed to work.
“Look,” Colt said, pointing to the bullet-ridden wall. “It’s art.”
She said nothing for a long time. When she did move, it was quick. She whirled on Colt, her fist flashed out, and he buckled over. Then she walked away, disappeared into the bathroom.
“Amber!” Colt roared. “I love you, Amber!”
The bathroom door opened a crack. Amber poked her head out and wrinkled her nose.
“Thanks.”
*
Colt was more dangerous sober than drunk; I think that’s why Amber never said much about his drinking. As I spent more time with them, I noticed she seemed tired. She carried herself the same way my mother did whenever I inevitably limped back to her doorstep: shoulders perpetually drooped, arms forever open.
One night, after attending a party none of us really wanted to go to, we all piled into Amber’s car. It was late. Colt was driving, so he wasn’t wasted. The combination of both of those things was probably what led to our next set of problems.
We stopped at a red light, surrounded by darkened windows and profane graffiti, three minutes from Colt and Amber’s place. A pick-up truck pulled up next to us, one with oversized tires and a comically small body, and I made a groggy note to myself that if I ever saw that thing parked somewhere, I’d piss on it. Its whole construction was offensive.
The truck’s window rolled down and a hand appeared, holding a flask. The hand turned, poured the contents onto the street. The liquid shone like blood under the glare of the red light. Something was shouted. Before the light turned, the truck rocketed away.
“He’s it,” Colt said.
Amber jerked up in her seat.
“No,” she said. “He’s not.”
Her voice quavered. I’d never heard her voice quaver before. I wondered if I should be afraid. I wondered why I wasn’t.
“He’s it.”
“If you do this I’m—”
The tyres screeched, flayed themselves against the asphalt. We lurched forward. The buildings blurred until one became indistinguishable from the other. I buckled my seatbelt.
Amber turned back to me.
“Say something!”
I just blinked at her. She should’ve known better than to expect rational discourse. Her gravitational pull dwarfed mine. It was ridiculous to think that I had any insight into this absurd scenario and how to force a favourable outcome. When she realised I had nothing to say, she snarled, turned away and did not look at me again.
We caught the truck, almost kissing bumpers. They tossed something at us, something heavy enough to leave a small spider-web of cracks on the windshield. That didn’t faze Colt. I caught a glimpse of his eyes in the rearview mirror. Glazed over, like orbs of polished glass.
Colt reached for the glove compartment. Amber got there first. Amber pointed the gun at Colt’s head.
“Amber!” I squealed. “Put that thing down!”
She ignored me.
“Pull over.”
Colt said nothing. Amber cocked back the hammer.
We slowed. The truck disappeared out of sight. We stopped on the side of the road, and we just sat there, idling and simmering in the heat of the moment.
“Get out of the car,” Amber said. “Both of you.”
We did as we were told. Amber shifted over to the driver’s seat and drove away.
I saw her again a few times, after the whole thing had quieted down. I don’t think Colt did. If he had realised she was leaving for good, he would’ve sprinted after her, shouting and blurring the lines between obscenity and apology. But he didn’t know, so he just sat down right on the sidewalk, sighed and shook his head.
“He was it.”
*
Without Amber, things fell apart between me and Colt. I saw him trying to be better, to let go of whatever insidious dreams he had, but they had infected him beyond repair. When he attempted good, harm was born. He tried to break up fights only to ignite wars. Once, he intervened in what he mistakenly thought was an abusive relationship and had to pay the couple off so they wouldn’t press charges. He talked of going back to Amber after balancing his karma, but the universe was determined to deny him salvation.
I cut him out when I ran into him at a friend’s house. I let myself in and saw Colt and a few others standing around a man on the floor. The man’s scalp leaking blood, maybe more.
“He’s not dead,” Colt said. Then, as if this made everything okay, “I called an ambulance.”
There were murmurs of agreement. The man sat up, rubbed his cracked head, then covered his mouth.
“I need a bucket,” the man said.
There was a destiny in Colt. I didn’t want to share it. I cut him out without saying anything. Everyone did and that was why he didn’t fight to hang onto any connections. When outnumbered and outmatched, the best thing to do is move on.
I wasn’t surprised when I learned from Amber, months later, that Colt had landed in prison for manslaughter. I acted shocked, because that’s how people expected me to act, but I wasn’t. She continued. The shock became real.
It had all been a fluke. An accident. No violent intent. He’d just sped across an intersection at the wrong time and struck down an elderly woman who had outlived both her children and bore a sacred innocence cherished by all, comprehended by none. Colt had tried to save her; he staunched her wounds with his bare hands and flooded her lungs with his own rancid breath. Even after she slipped away, he kept on trying to bring her back, as if performing a miracle would not only redeem her life, but his own. The paramedics had to drag him away from the corpse.
Given his past and the way he carried himself, the jury saw him as a menace. He was given the maximum sentence. Any hope of parole, years down the line. I was relieved. That was the end of it.
My phone rang. I only picked up because I was out of work again and expecting a call from a distant relative who I hoped would give me money. I sat there, slack-jawed and numb, when Colt’s voice rattled across the speaker.
“You sound scared,” Colt said.
“I’m not,” I lied.
“Yeah? How about a visit.”
How could I say no? The guilt over deserting Colt had certainly faded over time, but his voice had ripped off my scab of indifference. There was no baulking. I needed to know. I needed to see.
His head was shaved and his beard was trimmed and he had gained weight in muscle. He wore an orange jumpsuit. He flashed his teeth, I think to distract me from the smell of dull panic leaking from his pores. Below his eye there was a tattoo of a teardrop, pointing in the wrong direction, as if it had decided to defy gravity in hopes of returning to where it came from, to the holy orb.
I pondered the significance of this. I gathered the courage to ask.
“It was a mistake,” Colt said. “It doesn’t mean anything.”
*
On the way out, I recognised the med student, the one I mentioned earlier and had known only briefly. He saluted as I walked by, like we had run into each other at a restaurant. I waved back and swallowed and almost tripped as I fled toward the exit. What could he have done to end up here, this amicable man to whom life had given every opportunity?
It didn’t take me long to find out—a quick online search revealed all. He’d butchered someone over a minor disagreement. For some reason he’d thought the best way to cover his tracks was to toss the body into a dumpster on the other side of town; but not before peeling back its flesh and gazing at the silent heart beneath, the organ he was desperate to understand. His crimes, at best, had been committed in moments of temporary insanity, and the defence held. He would probably be on the streets before Colt.
I found a picture of the med student, a smiling portrait I couldn’t pry myself away from. The slight upturn of his lips, the demure creases around his eyes, it all seemed so natural. I imagined the photo had come about by chance, that it had been taken by a passing photographer who had stumbled upon the artist’s Holy Grail, a candid moment of someone happy to be alive. It was the antithesis of Colt also, who has always been framed by harsh light and clenched teeth, even when he walked free.
Still, I can’t help but think that if the three of us stood side by side in a lineup, no one would be able to tell us apart. Not even our mothers.
THE END
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Blake’s stories have appeared in various rags, including Hypnopomp Literary Magazine, Tales from the Moonlit Path, and Bridge Eight.
His noir-toned novella, Prodigal: An American Parable, will be released soon by small publisher Trouble Department, and his urban fantasy novel, God-Box, is forthcoming from Literary Wanderlust.
on Twitter: @bjohnsonauthor

